
Scotland’s most famous romantic conjurer of Caledonian mysticism is misunderstood in the black metal community. Andy Marshall distances himself from nationalism these days in case it be mistaken for the neo-Nazi NSBM strain. Instead, Saor venerates the landscape and solitude-inspiring mountains of Alba and touches upon the more optimistic fresh-air invigoration of Celtic folk melody as a counterpart to the experimental thrash metal at the heart of Marshall’s compositions. You never know what to expect from the structure of a Saor record or how much of the music will include vocals, and album number four retains the trademark intrigue of earlier releases in the discography.
Those of us bored to death by the persistent attempt by Scottish romantic nationalists to rewrite the Highlander clans as a European Samurai have nothing to fear here. Yes, Marshall draws upon the signature Dorian scales of Celtic folk music for the emotional impact, but he seldom overdoes it to the point of saturation. Opener, ‘Call of the Carnyx’, starts with an enchanting chord-picked progression and harmonised guitar notes you’d expect to hear in a sixteenth-century flute piece. It’s more Outlander than Highlander, yet the thrash metal tempo and sudden switch to a bass-baritone choir arrangement in the opening verse lend it an eclecticism that never degenerates into incongruency.
Of course, the occasional cliché rears its head on Origins. Does any modern artist experimenting with field sounds ignore the crackling sensation of burning twigs when the mood demands an environment you can touch and feel? It’s a pleasant start to ‘Fallen’, but the mid-tempo metal riffs in the background remain innocuous, like the latter-day Therion records. Here, Marshall inserts the standard palm-muted rhythms as an afterthought to the poignancy of the instrumentation. ‘The Ancient Ones’ is better and more assured of its purpose. Listen to the Aeolian melody of the guitars as they lead the double-kick drums like a shepherd directing his flock. It makes you realise all along that Gregor MacKintosh of Paradise Lost has a fondness for the Celtic scales and might not know it. Maybe the Yorkshire legends are the main influence on the expressive lead guitar lines of Marshall, who, likewise, might not know it.
The atmospheric black metal at the heart of Saor finds no expression in tiresome tremolo riffs, and that’s a good thing. Even the blast beats are sparse here. ‘Aurora’ is the closest we come to a moment that promises transcendence, like English prog metal quartet, Countless Skies, at their most effulgent. The sorrowful guitar lines emerge through the excitement at the calming point of satisfaction, where you can take a breather and celebrate the simplicity of being alive with no foreboding. How clever of Marshal to follow this with a triumphant piece of atmospheric black metal on ‘Beyond the Wall’, when most of his contemporaries would seek the comfort of an impenetrable noise cloud drowned in sinister menace. Even the frenetic death-thrash segments in the middle sparkle with crimson red rather than black and grey.
As a self-declared purveyor of “Caledonian metal”, Andy Marshall comes ever closer to reaching his ideal with Origins. Whether this type of art will ever manifest into an unstoppable sub-genre of metal is another question and depends on how much you can tolerate Celtic folk music.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 24/06/2022
Record Label: Season of Mist
Standout tracks: Aurora, Beyond the Wall
Suggested Further Listening: Hand of Kalliach – Samhainn (2021), Primordial – To the Nameless Dead (2007), Fuath – II (2021)
