
How do you continue with your band when you’ve lost the greatest prog-metal drummer of all time in Sean Reinert (RIP)? This is a question Cynic co-founder, Paul Masvidal, must ponder on a regular basis. As a progenitor of jazz fusion in metal and the lead guitarist on the best metal album of all time on Death’s 1991 Human LP, Masvidal has a legacy that sparkles like the interiors of the Palace of Versailles. Cynic’s 2008 comeback record won universal acclaim at the time but underwhelmed this reviewer due to the weak vocal harmonies and abstract song structures. 2014’s Kindly Bent to Free Us was not much better despite the good will of the prog metal community. Now Masvidal has Australian guitar virtuoso, Plini, joining him and Nova Collective drummer, Matt Lynch, providing the complex rhythms. Could this be the Cynic album we’ve been waiting for as a worthy follow up to 1993’s classic Focus record?
Like most Cynic releases, this one will baffle you on first listen and might not be any clearer after another five spins. But that’s not to say it’s a frustrating experience – far from it. You could play Ascension Codes on a walking expedition through the Welsh valleys and absorb it into your body like a relaxing afternoon in an Icelandic geyser. ‘The Winged Ones’ evolves like a guitar-heavy version of 808 State floating through their classic ‘Magical Dream’ single. Masvidal might even be using a Moog in the latter parts, but you’re too busy marvelling at the jazz fusion drum patterns and expressive bass guitar to dwell on it. The synths and guitars are indistinguishable on ‘Mythical Serpents’, the melodies on another level that will require a degree in music theory to understand the modal elements of this composition.
A big reservation you might have about modern Cynic is the lack of death metal vocals and the possibility that Masvidal’s weak indie falsetto will dominate the songs (as was the case with their 2014 effort). The news is positive on this front: Masvidal offers a ghost-like multi-layered falsetto that slots into the translucent splendour of the music as just another instrument. ‘6th Dimensional Archetype’ shines like the progressive metal sophistication of a Plini record, which is all the more apparent now he’s a semi-permanent member of Cynic. Here, the palm-muted guitar technique receives its longest veneration among four minutes of Mahavishnu Orchestra soundscapes. Plini and Masvidal are at their best on the excellent ‘Architects of Consciousness’, with the singer employing a haunting tenor voice unseen on other Cynic records. Again, the synths and guitars are in union, like two snowflakes joining together under the coercion of gravity.
As with anything by Cynic, you can always find elements that prevent you from enjoying the full experience. Here, the decision to insert thirty-second interludes between each full-length composition takes the track listing to eighteen, when nine would suffice. There’s also a feeling that the two guitarists are too sophisticated to rip through a shredding solo or deliver anything as revolutionary as a power chord in their music. When you reach the end, you ask the same question: What the hell is this? Is it prog rock, avant-garde, electronic art rock? You know it’s clever and original, but it lacks a special something that remains indefinable and elusive.
Ascension Codes is a stronger effort than its 2014 predecessor and demonstrates that Cynic can continue after Sean Reinert. Paul Masvidal is an unorthodox musical thinker, yet his visions might be too far ahead of their time for us mortals to comprehend them.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 26/11/2021
Record Label: Season of Mist
Standout tracks: The Winged Ones, 6th Dimensional Archetype, Architects of Consciousness
Suggested Further Listening: Plini – Impulse Voices (2020), 808 State – Ninety (1989), Between the Buried and Me – Colors II (2021)
