
Finland’s Mortyfear formed in the late 1990s, yet this is only their second album following a sporadic release of EPs and various line-up changes. Now the quintet are confident enough to declare they’ve nailed down their true sound after much experimentation, and it’s an audio assault that will baffle as much as it bedazzles. If you want bizarre and unpredictable genre-hopping and spooky keyboards, you’re in the right place.
The chances are you’ll invert your eyebrows and screw up your face on hearing the first ten seconds of ‘Circus Called Life’. Is this a cheap attempt at creating the theme tune for Creepshow III? What the fuck is going on? After a minute, you start to compute what’s happening. Is this a nu metal version of Macabre? Then the dual vocal approach takes over and eases you into a more extreme metal setting. You’re not sure what hit you when it comes to an end, but you’ll wonder if Primus might sound like this with a mandate to play death metal. The bewilderment does not abate on ‘Jester’s Downfall’. This one is more of a head-banger, like Mike Patton’s Fantomas fusing cinematic horror with thrash riffs.
You’re in for a rude awakening if you think the eerie cinematic effects are a novelty of the first few songs. ‘Plastic World’ uses syncopated chug riffs and evokes Billy Idol, yet it also has a serious message about the unsustainability of using plastic as part of our everyday lives. ‘Black Noise’ is a death metal ballad as imagined by Carach Angren and makes excellent use of a gothic doh-ray-mi-fa-so scale at the beginning. It could descend into a car crash at the turn of a note, but that’s what makes it enthralling.
One can admire the imagination and rich iconoclasm running through Mortyfear’s approach to heavy music, but two things stop them from making the most of their experiment. First of all, the guitars need to be louder and more thoughtful in their menacing execution. Too often, they insert the riffs in as the last piece of the puzzle. French eclectic metallers, Psykup, are the masters at getting the balance right between brutal metallic riffing and sinister pop silhouettes, and Mortyfear could do well to study them. ‘Spoiled’ and ‘Delete’ pulsate with promise but fall victim to dilution and rely too much on the death metal gutturals to intimidate the listener. This album needs a couple of straight-up metal bangers to even out the sound, just as Faith No More spiced up The Real Thing with ‘Surprise! You’re Dead!’ and ‘Zombie Eaters’.
Mortyfear take the broken ballerina box, the cobwebs and the cracked mirror as their aesthetic and show they can make it work in the first half of My Dystopia. Closing track, ‘Dark Waters’, salvages this good work with tribal drums and spooky female harmonies. The guitars may be more Evanescence than Entombed, but the Finnish quintet make a virtue of their unpredictability here and leave you wanting more.
With their output limited to just two LPs in over two decades, you fear if Mortyfear will have enough time to perfect the admirable ideas explored on My Dystopia. They might be on the cusp of something original and should not be afraid to continue down this road in the future. Throw in a few more thrash metal nuggets and they could have the ear of the wider underground on the next outing.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 15/07/2021
Record Label: Inverse Records
Standout tracks: Circus Called Life, Jester’s Downfall, Plastic World
Suggested Further Listening: Terravoid – Ectogenesis EP (2021), Fantomas – The Director’s Cut (2001), Psykup – Ctrl + Alt + Fuck (2017)
