Borstal – At Her Majesty’s Pleasure EP


Few musicians can boast the pedigree and talent of Nick Barker over the years. Having occupied the studio drum stool for Cradle of Filth, Dimmu Borgir and Brujeria and filled in as live drummer for Testament, Exodus and Anaal Nathrakh during the last two decades, any band featuring Barker is worth your time as a metal fan, especially when he turns up in a UK hardcore outfit like Borstal. To see him in an NWA t-shirt stood next to four of the hardest tattooed skinheads in London will pique your interest even more.

Borstal’s debut EP is a clear declaration that UK hardcore (UKHC) still has a sound and aesthetic of its own. What could be more punk and working class than a band named after the nation’s most feared juvenile detention centre made famous by the classic Scum film with Ray Winston in 1979? Opener, ‘Refuse to Lose’ starts like ‘We Gotta Know’ from the legendary Cro-Mags debut with distorted chords and a regular beat set to snippets of social commentary and television interviews about the causes of street crime. You might not have any hairs left on your chest after the scorching metallic hardcore attack that follows. With Knuckledust legend, Pierre Mendivil, leading the vitriolic gang vocals, you know it won’t be a stale affair, not with so much righteous anger flowing through his larynx.

Borstal are at their best when in crossover mode, i.e. when playing like thrash maniacs rather than confrontational street punks. ‘Karma’ is a bruiser, much like the tormentors that ran Borstal in its heyday. Close your eyes and it could be a thrash metal song but with less finesse and more of a hooligan approach. Unfortunately, they spoil the good work on the opening two tracks with the awful chord choices and Oi! punk of ‘We Stand as One’. Imagine the man who thumps you in the face after you spill a pint on his arm by accident. This is what we’re dealing with here – pure thuggery and the worst clichés of Sham 69. The social message might be of social relevance, but the loutish rage and deliberate attempt to sound sloppy is more irksome than an afternoon with a drunken punk anarchist rehearsing the soundbites he remembers from a friend’s crude rundown of the works of Pierre-Joseph Proudhon.

But this is a band featuring Nick Barker. We know it will be heavy and close enough to extreme metal to keep us interested. They don’t disappoint on ‘Vicious Circles’, the nearest they come to a Slayer workout with only the rogue vocals of the chorus putting a dampener on things. And of course, this wouldn’t be a UKHC album without a d-beat salute to the glory of Discharge on ‘Worm Food’, which relies less on tempo than you’d expect in attempting to ram home its power and purpose. You might even consider the guitar chords on ‘King of the Jungle’ as dark and moody before they launch into a full-blown hardcore punk stomp. Nothing can tame Borstal when they’re in top gear and have you in their sights.

It may not match the intensity of the latest Utilitarian EP, but At Her Majesty’s Pleasure knows how to drag you out of the crowd and into the alleyway. You won’t get a kicking, but Borstal will expect you to tool up and get behind them as they clear the scum from the streets.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 01/04/2021

Record Label: Rucktion Records

Standout tracks: Refuse to Lose, Vicious Circles

Suggested Further Listening: Utilitarian – Stay Angry EP (2020), Cro-Mags – The Age of Quarrel (1986), Nasty – Menace (2020)