
Iced Earth guitarist, Jake Dreyer, quit the band when news broke that the FBI had Jon Schaffer on their most wanted list for his part in the storming of the Capitol City building in January this year. Demons & Wizards also folded in disgust at Schaffer’s insurgent behaviour, but we can thank the metal gods that Dreyer still has Witherfall to fall back on for his virtuoso guitar skills. Now on their third album, and featuring members of Chon and Sanctuary, Witherfall are not about to disappear anytime soon, not when they can focus their minds on writing progressive heavy metal of such high calibre.
If you haven’t heard Dreyer shred, you’re in for a treat. This man is like a thrash metal Beethoven, fusing James Hetfield and the neo-classical with the wizardry of Jeff Loomis. ‘The Last Scar’ is And Justice For All-era Metallica interpreting Dream Theater. Is it power metal, thrash metal, prog metal? Who cares when it rocks like a motherfucker and unleashes a triumphant chorus that Geddy Lee would love to have in his repertoire? See if you can keep your mouth zipped and your arms by your side as vocalist, Joseph Michael, unfurls a chorus refrain of “I saw the light and it burned/ This is the last scar/ You’ve crossed the line and I’ll make you learn/ I saw the light and it burned.” Well, this reviewer saw the light, and it did burn.
The drum and bass rhythm section in ‘As I Lie Awake’ is extraordinary in its precision. You can say the same for ‘Another Face’, which starts with enchanting acoustic guitar arpeggios and gives way to five minutes of chunky riffing and an outro of Psychotic Waltz proportions. Jim Matheos of Fates Warning is as much of an influence as Dream Theater’s Awake LP from 1994 on ‘Tempest’. Push out those lips and narrow your eyes to Dreyer’s pitch bends and marvel at the lightning speed of the thrash metal palm-muting. A helping of fretless bass soloing should keep your excitement levels up. If you don’t like it, you’re the nerd, not this reviewer!
Any band that draws inspiration from Death’s Symbolic masterpiece deserves your attention, and the instrumental thrash extravagance of ‘The Unyielding Grip of Each Passing Day’ is one for you to nod along to with mouth agape. In fact, this type of heavy power metal is all Chuck Schuldiner listened to in the last few years of his life. There’s no doubt he’d be giving the horns of approval to ‘The Other Side of Fear’, especially the fast triplet riff that follows the muscular chorus. “I’m falling through shadows/ They follow me close behind/ I wander through this nightmare/ Til’ I reach the other side/ The other side of fear,” roars Joseph Michael with a clenched fist and snarling nostrils.
Perhaps the greatest strength of this record is its ability to keep you enthralled for the long-form compositions. ‘…And They all Blew Away’ is fifteen minutes of guitar wizardry and King Diamond theatrics with a monumental key change from bridge to chorus. But one criticism persists throughout Curse of Autumn. Some of the choruses are a bit too Bachman Turner Overdrive/ REO Speedwagon. This is a heavy metal album rooted in the 1980s but stained by the occasional pop-rock vocal harmonies of the 1970s. It’s a good job Dreyer’s thrash heroics and the band’s obsession with extended heavy metal shredding are there to distract us from some of the more AOR moments.
Be shameless in your bedazzlement when you spin this record. This is virtuoso prog metal with a few clichés but many highlights.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 05/03/2021
Record Label: Century Media
Standout tracks: The Last Scar, Tempest, The Other Side of Fear
Suggested Further Listening: Dream Theatre – Awake (1994), Detritus – Myths (2021), Iced Earth – Horror Show (2001)
