Ancient Thrones – Melancholia


‘No band thought it conceivable to write the metal version of Ingmar Bergman’s The Seventh Seal, but this Nova Scotia quartet are not just any band,’ said Scream Blast Repeat of the 2020 debut album by Ancient Thrones. We called it ‘a remarkable journey for the contemplative mind’ and wondered how they could top it on their next effort. Here we are, five years later, for an undertaking that’s almost impossible. Melancholia is a good metal album, but it’s not the great one we need, despite its slimmer and heavier approach.

They take us right to the centre of the falling aircraft disaster in opener, ‘A Moon Fused Key’, like Morbid Angel derailed by Mayhem. Sean Hickey’s vocal projections are as fiendish as ever despite blast-beating his way through the verses from the drum stool. The five years were worth the wait on the evidence of this obliterating piece of extreme metal. Tremolo rhythms have no time to settle, drum fills abound, inhumane guttural words give way to savage screams, and yet you can hear the dissonant sci-fi of Voivod underneath the carnage. The last two minutes fade out in a blaze of sweep-picking melodies and segue into the thoughtful piano scales of ‘Achromatopsia’ for a brief interlude at track two.

The Canadians wanted to move beyond the poetic and hopeful elements of their debut when creating this LP. Delivering on this promise restricts the emotional rollercoaster that listeners need to see past the relentless pummelling that makes most black and death metal so boring these days. The action is faster than a surface-to-ship missile in the title-track. Slow down some of the guitar shapes and they’d qualify as a neo-classical if you could hear them with more clarity. Fortunately, Ancient Thrones understand the importance of the latter, which explains the decision to reset at 02:33 to piano sprinkles and looping arpeggios. Hickey coughs up blood to expel the words from his stomach when the dynamics shift once again towards full velocity.

Of course, there’s a lot to admire here if you limit your judgement to the quality of the extreme metal on offer. Can you work out the subtle off-meter time signature in the intro to ‘A Turning Point’? The death metal angle is strongest in the structuring of the riffs and the technical accomplishments needed to produce them. Impossible finger shapes and a solid picking hand are the minimum requirements to fulfil the role of axeman in this band.

Musically, Ancient Thrones writhe in pain and seek expression in the release of anxiety. Yet their determination to annihilate the listener in ‘A Pellucid Prism’ narrows the solemn resonance that made songs like ‘Divided/Dissolve’ from the last LP so compelling. ‘A Pale Palace’ is what you get when you add a splash of discordance to a traditional heavy metal palate. It’s the only time they build a two-beat drum combination in the verses and let the riffs do the talking as Hickey growls his way through the abyss. When they go up a gear, they do so like four musicians playing at autonomous speeds with deliberate incoordination. Too often, the sputtering guitar intervals and grisly vocals conjure images of a killer cyborg in need of a reboot before it kills everyone in sight. Take ‘Sacred Swollen Glass’ as an example where the homicidal rage burns bright. Imagine being in the electric chair for six minutes and sixteen seconds. The intensity levels will frazzle you until 02:10, where they entangle you in another run of bludgeoning offbeats.

This record lacks a distinctive atmosphere because of its obsession with speed over substance. Hickey sounds like a victim of terror rather than a perpetrator of it for most of the action. Only in closing track, ‘Vacant’, do Ancient Thrones produce something of greater depth, using keyboards to add a mystical dimension to the demonic death-doom. Melancholia is the album Ancient Thrones felt compelled to make, but they already proved their extreme metal credentials in 2020, and this feels like a safe option rather than an innovative one.


Verdict


Release Date: 19/09/2025

Record Label: Self-released

Standout track: A Moon Fused Key; A Turning Point; A Pale Palace

Suggested Further Listening: King ov Wyrms – Lord ov Thornes (2020), Abhoria – Abhoria (2021), Panzerchrist – Maleficium Part 2 (2025)