
Seldom do you encounter a band that formed for the explicit purpose of honouring their heroes. In this case, the raison d’être of Gruesome is to pay homage to the greatness of Death and Chuck Schuldiner. One can understand the passion for something like this project. Death are probably the finest metal band of all time. Silent Echoes is the third full-length offering in the Gruesome discography, and now they turn their attention to Death’s 1991 masterpiece, Human. The question is not why, but what’s the point?
A thoughtful caress of the harmonic minor scales opens track one, ‘Condemned Identity’, before the amps blister through with sharp thrash metal riffing. Like Sean Reinert’s drumming style on Human, the footwork is sublime. The bass is louder and more prominent in the mix, which feels like a correction to the original record. You can’t fault the energy or the execution of the instruments. In fact, you could believe this was an album written and recorded by Chuck Schuldiner if you close your eyes. Listen to the rapid alt-picking techniques against the guitar strings as they grind like a precision mechanism drill.
Let’s be clear: the aim here is to emulate an opus by another artist without covering the original songs. ‘A Darkened Window’ starts like ‘Suicide Machine’ (track two on Human) but creates its own materials. It’s admirable how Gruesome recreate the Scott Burns production here as well as the prowess of Death. Maybe we should see this as Sebastian Faulkes writing a Bond novel to continue the Ian Fleming series thirty years later. The riffs fly about like physical matter brought to life by a master alchemist. Likewise, they share the same thrill as those from the hand of Schuldiner in ‘Frailty’.
Unfortunately, the lack of any other influence makes Silent Echoes more of an idle curiosity than an essential piece of art. Praising a death metal band for being a faithful tribute to their heroes comes with awkward questions about ambition and relevance. What more can one say other about the likes of ‘Shards’ and ‘Voice Within the Void’ other than the musicianship is stupendous and the delivery is as close to Death as you can get? The same start-stop modulations emerge in the former like Reinert and Schuldiner in telepathic harmony. The lyrics to the title-track could be from any of the final four albums in the Chuck Schuldiner canon. ““Surrounded by silence, in an isolated world / Remembered words, now so far away,” roars Matt Harvey as if appearing on an old episode of Stars in their Eyes for a death metal special.
It’s hard to get excited about a tribute album, just as it’s hard to be thrilled by the prospect of sex with a blow-up doll instead of a woman. Their musical skill is sublime, and you can’t deny the passion of Matt Harvey and co., but that’s not the point. Even those exquisite riffs like the labyrinthine pull-offs in ‘Reason Denied’ fail to move you.
Silent Echoes is a replica, so why bother with it when you can listen to the real thing or a modern piece of progressive death metal by Fallujah or Rivers of Nihil?
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 06/06/2025
Record Label: Relapse Records
Standout tracks: Condemned Identity; Shards; Reason Denied
Suggested Further Listening: Death – Human (1991)
