
London metalcore quartet, Confessions of a Traitor, are all about fortitude, but they believe that profound loss can be overcome through self-analysis. How do you find hope again after a devastating loss? It’s no surprise that they identify as a Christian metal band, and that should not work against them. But you wonder if eleven songs that refuse to deviate from an established metalcore orthodoxy is worth your time.
The Londoners are happy to oblige in case you need a reminder of the importance of nu metal on modern metalcore in opener, ‘Starve’. Meaty syncopated guitars and shoulder-swaying drum grooves provide the foundations for Stephen MacConville to roar his way through the song to lament: “One day this pain will serve you.” We assume he’s looking at his reflection in the mirror.
This Pain Will Serve You is heavy. It’s loud and violent, but there are so many other bands doing this as their thing. Jacob Brand and Jack Darnell could be more imaginative in their riffing rather than relying on the power of their down-tuned instruments. ‘Fatal Frame’ is like Monuments minus the technical brilliance. But if you’re in the same headspace, it could speak to you and help you vent. Even the dual harmony chorus with a strain of clean vocals is listenable to the ears of a hardened headbanger. Not so for ‘Doomsayer’. Piano notes resonate like delicate footprints on ice in the intro before the axemen go berserk, and MacConville loses his mind. The chorus here is more of an annoyance rather than a ritual for the listening congregation. ‘Midnight Sun’ gives you the formula as if revealing a basic equation to use in all future endeavours. It’s a race to the scream-along section, but the listener would benefit from something different.
The age rule holds for this album. Only men over thirty form sludge metal bands, just as nobody under thirty begins with this type of metalcore. It’s remarkable how easy it is to absorb the aggression of ‘Still Haunted’ to the point where it becomes fangless. You can’t forget the chorus here – they repeat it until it makes your eyes bleed. How many times can you scream, “I’m still haunted by your silhouette”?
Confessions of a Traitor are like an underdog boxer who lacks the killer instinct to reach the top of their weight division. As you’d expect, injecting a note of sorrow into metalcore is what makes it so unlistenable (see ‘Love You Left Behind’). Is there a genre more unsuited to this mood? Killswitch Engage must find it hard to sleep at night knowing that their music led to something as anodyne as this.
But this LP is about finding positives, and so should we. The guitars in ‘The Sins I’ve Yet to Answer’ dig into your skin like acupuncture and leave you feeling refreshed. This is more like it. You can feel your nostrils expanding under the weight of the riffs. It could even pass for a mosh pit anthem from Heart of a Coward. Likewise, the high tempo of closing track, ‘Half Life’, is its greatest asset, but the palm-muted jabs are also welcome. “The reaper knows my God-forsaken name,” is the message here.
There’s no doubt that this band have groove to back up their swerving guitar riffs. They also have conviction. So, why does it feel functional rather than therapeutic?
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 16/05/2025
Record Label: Facedown Records
Standout tracks: Fatal Frame; Still Haunted; The Sins I’ve Yet to Answer
Suggested Further Listening: Grayscale Season – Do You Like Violence (2022), Invent Animate – Heavener (2023), Like Moths to Flames – The Cycles of Trying to Cope (2024)
