
Quebec unit, Scare, are cerebral about their non-cerebral music. Their aim is to “create anxiety-driven music for those feeling the pressure of the world.” That’s easy to do when you mix crust punk, hardcore and proto-black metal in the same dish. Anxiety is not something you can shape or control. It’s capricious, damaging, unpredictable. That’s what Scare create on their sophomore album. But, in the end, is it worth it?
Opener, ‘Nevermind if it all explodes, I’ll die anyway’, pulsates with nihilism. Think of it as rough punk plated in pentatonic coatings and extra fuzz. The vocals are lo-fi enough to pass for a demo, but there’s plenty of grit in the delivery. Its imperfections are glorious. You can hear the d-beat hardcore influence, yet the drummer also likes his double-timing techniques. If stoner metal had an aggressive edge, this is what it would sound like.
For much of this LP, you’ll feel like you’re in the rehearsal room with the band under the influence of hunger suppressants. ‘PMA: Pessimistic Mental Attitude’ makes good use of death metal tremolos filtered through a crust punk setting. Philip Roy’s approach to the microphone is to assault it with a single-tracked scream approach. Listen to the blast beats at the end when the song reaches its climax. How raw is this music? ‘Drifted Away’ is punk rock with a capital R in the riff-savvy guitar shapes.
An album of thirteen songs spread over thirty-two minutes should not be cumbersome, and you can’t accuse Scare of this flaw. Side A is exciting to the point where you might rip off your shirt and swing it over your head. ‘The Black Painting’ offers the first sign of a doom metal spell. Listen how the grungy guitars strike the power chords before they switch to a proto-black metal/Venom attack after forty seconds. By contrast, the pinch harmonics vibrate like a sludge metal guitarist defiling Van Halen’s memory in ‘Thrash Melrose’.
The main criticism of In the End, Was It Worth It? is how close these songs are in tone and key. But that’s to be expected with a crusty hardcore band that employs rock ’n’ roll solos and standard tunings. Mudhoney mixed with Necrofier is an easier way to view the genesis of this music. Scare have melody low down on their list of priorities. They want you to feel the wrath of their ugly noise. You might even call them a punk version of Napalm Death’s classic grindcore sound with a sparing use of blast beats.
The ambiguity of the words disguised by hysterical screams is more charming than you’d think. Likewise, Xavier Laprade loves his Dave Grohl fills in ‘Midnight Ride’. But can you tell it apart from a song like ‘Turbograine’? Instead, more efforts like ‘Harakiri Ton Industrie’ would elevate the listening experience on side B. It’s the most metal song on the record. Doom metal meets punk with an ethereal black metal ending. What’s not to like?
Scare’s punk rock seems designed to offend radio listeners. That’s how it should be. Song titles like ‘Reality of Death in the Maze of Hope’ do not roll off the tongue. Here, Philip Roy gets everything off his chest like a patient encouraged to verbalise his frustrations with life. It also produces one of the finest riffs on the record with a flamboyant tag at the end of each bar. Observe how the drummer and the axe woman, Gabrielle Noël-Bégin, lock into a palm-muted groove for the only time on the album. For a moment, you wonder if they might scythe you with a breakdown ritual (spoiler alert: they don’t).
Crusty metallic punk performed as if starving in the black hole of Calcutta might sound unappealing, but Scare’s second LP will keep you alive.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 21/02/2025
Record Label: Self-released
Standout tracks: PMA: Pessimistic Mental Attitude; Crowned in Yellow; Harakiri Ton Industrie
Suggested Further Listening: Averysadstory – Old Dark Memories (2023), Gorgonchrist – …And Justice for Balls (2024), Deadform – Entrenched in Hell (2024)
