
German sludge duo, Mantar, are popular in the metal music industry. Now on their sixth album, they’ve enjoyed stints on Svart Records and Nuclear Blast, and they present their latest material as clients of Metal Blade Records. Ask your average metal fan outside Deutschland if they know of them, and the answer will often be a puzzled facial expression. How do the self-declared “grungetown hooligans” shape up on Post Apocalyptic Depression? That depends if you like old school punk rock.
The duo plug in and play their instruments like a garage rock band with sludge metal settings in opener, ‘Absolute Ghost’. Entombed’s death ‘n’ roll is the obvious comparison. The vocals in this song resemble the croaky exhalation technique of Al Jourgensen (Ministry). A sinister metal flavouring tries to come through at various stages, but you can’t see past the rock ‘n’ roll swagger. ‘Rex Perverso’ is no different. Stoner rock is a better description. Mantar have the blues, and they want to deliver them through the prism of Green River. Take out the throat-heavy gutturals and this is quite orthodox, like The Hives under the influence of Venom.
You can fret the air guitar with a cigarette in your mouth or pull a shrieking black metal pose during ‘Principle of Command’. The head-banging drumbeats will keep you on edge, but the pentatonic riffs are disposable. This is derivative guitar music. Mudhoney would sound like this if you asked them to cover a song by The Stooges. Only the blood-thirsty vocals offer something of interest. These are full-spleen attack from the first word. You wonder how many microphones they mauled in the process of unleashing their misanthropy on to the world.
If there’s one saving grace, it’s that this LP is an easy listen. But it’s also safe, despite what the song titles say. ‘Pit of Guilt’ is one of twelve garage rock anthems on Post Apocalyptic Depression that soon loses its charm. It’s hard to stay engaged after track four. The energy is there, but the imagination is absent. No doubt, this would be more fun to watch in a live setting with a pint of beer in hand. Mantar have a wonderful sense of humour, which makes them more suited to the quirky grindcore of Beaten to Death than the punk rock of the 1980s. Going with the latter is anachronistic.
You could argue that Mantar recover their edge at the last stretch of this LP, but it’s too late. ‘Axe Death Scenario’ has the bones of grindcore and the energy of hardcore. ‘Cosmic Abortion’ puts less emphasis on rock ‘n’ roll and more weight behind sludge metal. They take the drum beat to ‘Immigrant Song’ by Led Zeppelin and beef up the guitars like the Melvins. We need more songs like this for this record to be anything other than a pastiche.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 14/02/2025
Record Label: Metal Blade
Standout tracks: Halsgericht; Axe Death Scenario; Cosmic Abortion
Suggested Further Listening: Black Void – Antithesis (2022), Therapy? – Shameless (2001), Kemerov – Anti-Hero (2022)
