
Readers of Scream Blast Repeat might wonder what happened to that great Portland gothic rock band, Idle Hands, who produced one of the finest albums of 2019. The answer is complicated. A trademark already existed for their former name, which forced them to change it in 2020 to Unto Others. Not only did they change their name, but they expunged Idle Hands from their catalogue, which means that their pre-2020 recordings are now recognised under their new moniker. But outside observers should not be alarmed. Their fanbase is happy that the quartet can still write and perform music, and you should be grateful, too. Never, Neverland is another masterpiece of modern songwriting.
You’ll spend most of this record looking for a formula. That’s because the core elements that produce the Idle Hands/Unto Others sound are easy to identify. The question is how a gothic/post-punk band in 2024 can be so good when most of their contemporaries are often a mere pastiche. Opener, ‘Butterfly’, is one of the easiest songs to grasp. Imagine melodic post-punk injected with the crunch of heavy metal. High-tempo drums and low-range vocals overpower the subtlety of the guitar work. You can hear The Sisters of Mercy and Bauhaus conversing with Type O Negative, yet the power chords throb like an intrusion into a cover of Echo & the Bunnymen.
Fifteen songs of this would soon lose potency, but Unto Others have a secret weapon – hard rocking proto-metal riffs. ‘Momma Likes the Door Closed’ is a shredding rock take on The Misfits with a metallic bassline and a frenzy of pentatonic guitars leading into the chorus. Here, the axemen indulge their heavy metal fantasies with a tasty succession of flamboyant fretwork, yet they make way for the bass in the middle eight to pay its homage to funk. Listen how the chorus nails down a deep vocal line that you expect to say, “Radio – live transmission,” in its hysteria. The same thing happens in ‘Sunshine’, where the dirty hard rock fights with a power pop melody in the opening riff. Rim clicks from the drummer work in perfect unison with the expressive guitar arpeggios. How easy is it for this band to deliver a memorable chorus? We often criticise musicians that want to be rock ‘n’ roll stars before they learn the art of songwriting, but Unto Others have earned the right to look like gothic rock icons in leather jackets and sunglasses.
The guitar arpeggios guide the melodies of this album like glow worms in the midnight woodlands. In classic goth rock fashion, it’s the bass that holds everything together with the drums maintaining a steady upfront beat. ‘Fame’ is mid-range power chord rock melded into an English post-punk paradigm. Listen how the vocal lines weave in and out of the basslines with an effortless tap of the shoe. Is there a more effective genre of music for injecting a sense of melancholy into its upbeat DNA? It’s a pleasure to follow the shaky baritone vocal lines as they descend through the scales in the chorus to ‘Angel of the Night’.
Songs like ‘Time Goes On’ and ‘Suicide Today’ remind us how to mix melodic guitar formations with a second channel of aggressive punk rock. The clean parts of the former could grace any album by The The or The Chameleons. But it’s the latter that deserves more analysis. This band recognise the key ingredients of what makes for exhilarating music – simple melodies, upbeat tempos, heroic guitars, tongue-in-cheek humour, and catchy choruses weighed down with a latent sorrow. Essentially, this is entertainment for outsiders who delight in living on the periphery of the mainstream. A sceptic would call it music aimed at precocious teenagers and introverted adults who identify with the nihilism because it masquerades as rebellion.
Unto Others know exactly what they want to achieve when they get together in the rehearsal room and before the pre-production phase. Can you place a hand on your heart and appreciate the tragic beauty of the dying world around you in ‘Cold World’? “We hang out by the riverside / We’ll float with the angels ’til we die / In the mountain meadows / Wild and free forever laughing,” sings Gabriel Franco. This song confirms that post-punk was a snapshot in time that came and conquered alternative culture in the 1980s and then fall by the wayside once the Americans produced their own culture through the medium of grunge. It had no place in the 1990s, but the back catalogues of many of its adherents continued to tower above those that displaced them. Any artist who dares to revisit this glory era when British and European bands held the attention of alienated American youth runs the risk of being a pastiche. Unto Others avoid this trap by inserting Type O Negative into their revivalist instincts (see ‘Flatline’).
The message of the closing title-track is that nothing will better The Cure, but this is everything you wanted from their discography, condensed into one album, with the addition of heavier guitars. Uh… Where is the repeat button, please?
Verdict


Release Date: 20/09/2024
Record Label: Century Media
Standout tracks: Momma Likes the Door Closed; Suicide Today; Cold World
Suggested Further Listening: The Chameleons – Script of the Bridge (1983), Naut – Hunt (2023), Stillborn – Netherworlds (2024)
