Theyrgy – Exit Strategies


This is an odd release to review for Scream Blast Repeat. Theyrgy is a Chicago collective with connections to a few notable bands from their hometown’s proggy-sludge metal scene (Yakuza, Yob, Indian, Lair of the Minotaur). A new band with those kinds of credentials come with some preconceived notions of how a collaboration between these guys should sound. But be prepared for any such expectations to go out the window.

As metal guys, the music here is pretty off-brand from the band’s regular gigs. It’s a mixed bag of disparate styles, running the gamut from synth pop, post punk, indie rock, noise rock and alt-light/ AOR rock.  These guys seem to get a kick out of subverting expectations for an audience not exactly known for being “open-minded”.

‘Crack of the Egg’ is sort of whimsical like a Modest Mouse song with the closest approximation of post punk styles and some interesting electronics and off-kilter rhythms. ‘Dream Catcher’ contrasts wistful verses against hopeful choruses. ‘Walk Away’ has a slick commercial vibe to it. It starts with a bouncy synth bassline and indie rock guitars. The vocals sound like Duran Duran and the song could be played in the elevator of a Marriot hotel. Then you start paying attention to the lyrics and realize the guy is singing about a cannibalistic serial killer.

‘Hiding your Face in the Wall’ is the most coherent song on this EP. Electronic beeps and chirps ricochet off industrial scrapes and burly noise rock, recalling later-day Killing Joke. If Theyrgy decided to just pick a style and wrote a whole album of songs like these, we could have a new classic on our hands…

Undoubtedly, there’s a lot to like about Exit Strategies. It’s cool to see musicians known for playing heavy music step out of their comfort zones to explore darkness from other angles than pure aggression and stale metal tropes. Theyrgy are quite capable of delivering contrasting moods from despair to joy from song to song. Hell, Katatonia made a whole career of doing just that. So, these guys are definitely on to something. They just aren’t there yet.

The main complaint is the overall lack of cohesion. It could be the sequencing – the shift of moods from track to track really breaks up the immersion. It comes off like Spotify playing random unrelated songs based on an algorithm. “Since you played Modest Mouse, Killing Joke, Joy Division, and early Ministry, we think you’ll enjoy these tracks too…”

Maybe these compositions would work better in the context of a full length. Theyrgy would have something way more compelling if they showed a more logical progression from light to dark, from track to track, like they could have done if they gave us three or four more songs to develop the vibe and flesh out these ideas.

Our advice: write some more fucking material, guys!

TB


Verdict


Release Date: 21/08/2020

Record Label: Dead Sage Records

Standout tracks: Hiding Your Face in the Wall, Crack of the Egg, Walk Away

Suggested Further Listening: Fugazi – Repeater (1990), Helmet – Meantime (1992), Dillinger Escape Plan – Under the Running Board (1997)