The Promise of Plague – Let Those Unjust Creatures Be Burnt


Jerry Barksdale (guitar, keyboards) and Jim Higgins (vocals, drums) created The Promise of Plague in 2016 as a basement project to channel their urges for a riskier and less constrained form of metal music. Enlisting the female contralto vocals of Ashley Vega allowed them to open vistas not available to their own gullets and set them on their way to record their debut industrial metal EP, Sleepwalking into Armageddon. Each subsequent release followed with a new departure of sound, to the point where they dropped the industrial elements on 2020’s Death Shrouds and Vomit Stains and focused their energies on death-grind with elements of classic rock. Now, they return with album number three and a new bass player to accompany them for their first trip to a proper recording studio. So why does Let Those Unjust Creatures Be Burnt have the feel of a CD-R demo from the 1990s?

The Promise of Plague are always in flux – that’s the point of their music. But it also leaves them open to a few pitfalls along the way. One thing you cannot criticise is their alacrity for merging contrasting metal sub-genres into one package. Opener, ‘Let All Your Dreams Be Damned’, piques your attention from the first note with solemn tom drum patterns and piano bass notes. Your nocturnal desires increase even more when the gothic doom guitars and melodramatic dual vocals enter the mix. The exaggerated rasp of Higgins’ growls provides a wonderful contrast with Vega’s husky voice to produce something akin to an extreme metal version of Ghost. This alone would be enchanting, but the band’s decision to squeeze three separate songs into one makes it even more enthralling. The second episode at 01:50 switches to a muscular thrash metal riffing and then resets to a surprise serenade of mystical singing and bass guitar soloing when you expect a return to the doom. Vega’s sultry voice will remind you of Tom G. Warrior’s vocal trade-offs with his female guests on Celtic Frost’s underrated Vanity/Nemesis. It’s an excellent start to the album.

But you should be worried when the best three tracks appear at the beginning of a record. ‘My Forever Tomb’ presents a hurricane of death metal that the band do not repeat elsewhere. You’d be forgiven for thinking this song belonged on a European record from the early 1990s rather than emerging from the repertoire of a group from Kentucky in 2023. The blast beats struggle to exert their true force under a barrage of cymbals, yet the high-range guitar phrasings in the chorus are clever. Vega’s contribution is more like a cameo here, but Higgins steals the limelight with a remarkable attempt to execute a death metal spoken word as the song heads towards its finale. The title-track is just as unorthodox. Fast alt-picking riffs and raw guttural vocals set you on a pathway through the Peaceville Records roster of 1991, but Vega ensures that it ends in the glorious repetition of a catchy vocal line spun through a sorrowful lament that would not be out of place on an Oceans of Slumber LP.

The abundance of ideas deserves praise, but the production quality does not match the ambition of its creators. You’ll hear an effective minor-key sequence of arpeggiated passages in the main riff to ‘Where My Shadows Can’t Reach You’, but the goblin vocals need no excuse to relinquish control of the song to Vega. This ought to be the sensible thing to do, but it fails to live up to its promise because it cannot decide if it wants to be a Rush song or an innocuous gothic metal pastiche. The traditional metal pomp of ‘Death Shrouds and Vomit Stains’ leaves Vega searching for her huskiest voice to command the song once the guitars revert to a dull vibration of power chords. But you’ll realise its charm if you persevere. Multi-personality vocal parts come together like something concocted at a drama school for heavy metal hopefuls. The high sophistication of the different voice arrangements will leave you humming them long after track five ends. This band are stubborn in their refusal to be pigeonholed into one sound.

Ending an album of twenty-eight minutes with a Manowar cover feels like an EP that evolved into a longer form of art rather than an LP that grappled with decisions about editing and cutting down superfluous material. The Promise of Plague are already writing for their next record, and you wonder if Let Those Unjust Creatures Be Burnt is a transition piece that will help them navigate to the next chapter of their career. There’s no doubt their next release will be a thrilling affair, but will it scale up the production and help them realise their true potential now they have a permanent bass player and a settled line-up for the live circuit?

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 08/09/2023

Record Label: Self-released

Standout tracks: Let All Your Dreams Be Damned; My Forever Tomb; Let Those Unjust Creatures Be Burnt

Suggested Further Listening: Celtic Frost – Vanity/Nemesis (1990), Amaurot – …To Tread the Ancient Waters (2022), Tribunal – The Weight of Remembrance (2023)