Sumac and Moor Mother – The Film


Aaron Turner’s quest to create a metal equivalent of free jazz on Sumac’s 2024 album, The Healer, received praise from Scream Blast Repeat. We liked its ‘emphasis on improvisation and no concern for traditional song structures’, so it makes sense to team up with somebody from the world of free jazz who’s also turned the idea of hip hop on its head. Camae Ayewa (aka Moor Mother) released her debut album in 2016 replete with a 122-page poetry book and has gone on to front free jazz collective, Irreversible Entanglements. This is her first collaboration with a metal artist, and it’s one that should pique the attention of anybody that values experimental music. It’s also a challenging record that’ll invite a few sighs as well as moments of nodding head approval.

Opener, ‘Scene 1’ sees a deep, blues-inflected chant to introduce Moor Mother’s acerbic rhymes as Aaron Turner and Co. slash at their instruments in distortion. The Maryland native has a wonderful range of dynamics for a rapper. Her words are more suited to a sermon; the anti-imperial diatribe will stop you eating your plate of noodles with your chopsticks in mid-air. You can imagine the irises of her eyes expanding with every word as her anger rises and falls like the coming together of a rugby scrum. Musically, this is noise rock without drums. Humming amps and single bass notes create a cacophony of urban pollution. You can almost taste the fumes.

‘Scene 2: The Run’ is the most difficult section of the record. It begins with three minutes of a violent single bass stroke reverberating like the sewage pipes of a pumping station. Eerie tremolo techniques will force you to be on guard as technical interruptions permeate through the mix via the plugging and unplugging of electric leads. A spasm of sludge metal emerges at 03:10 but then settles down again to the loud thud of a single bass note. Moor Mother has a vicious snarl in her vocal delivery. Many of the lyrics seem improvised under the blaze of a righteous fury. “I was running / Back to myself / Back to home / What do we return to?” she says in a frenzy. Listen to her frantic breath control. This is far more terrifying than a man in corpse paint venting his spleen. The new modulation at 08:06 is too far detached from the previous section to allow continuity, but the sludgy drop-tuned riffing born from this interregnum is worth the wait. Aaron Turner gathers the saliva at the back of his throat to produce his meanest death metal gutturals as the guitars circle the beats in filthy glee.

The easy thing to do here is to be uncritical because of the intellectual pretensions of its creators. We know The New York Times, Libération and the BBC will enjoy this work because its politics are progressive and on the right side of history. On a musical level, the extent of freeform jamming is minimal. Most of the sonics could be from an idle soundcheck where loose leads, excess feedback, and thoughtless bass musings drone with little imagination. The angelic soprano musings of Candice Hoyes in ‘Hard Truth’ provide a rare moment of luminescence despite the abrasive pedal loop glitches trying to force an unwanted paradox on the listener.

Undoubtedly, the star performer here is Moor Mother. The most remarkable aspect of her voice is the way it creates a sense of urgency as if tomorrow cannot wait for the changes that need to be made today. “America pissed and shit itself / No diaper / Obituaries and death don’t need no writer,” she declares in ‘Scene 3’. You’ll forget when the doom metal entered the fray as you follow the vitriol of the words. Even an Englishman like this reviewer can identify a southern drawl in her accent. ‘Scene 4’ is how we wanted to Swans to evolve after Children of God rather than the folkish post-rock that followed. A stubborn staccato thud of bass provides the time keeping as heavenly choir vocals cry in the background. The anger is fierce enough to make your nostrils tighten. “Nobody told me / Need to escape from the time matrix / Religious hatred / Love has been reinstated / Nobody told me / So long they’ve been hating, waiting, debating how to keep you enslaved / Better lose your mind,” thunders Moor Mother.

Screeching fret noises and wild drum fills start the proceedings in ‘Camera’. Unfortunately, it sounds like Sumac entered the studio, plugged in, had no conversations about beats or rhythms, and then twiddled the knobs on their amps for eight minutes as if imitating a day in the life of Kevin Shields from My Bloody Valentine. The drums come and go like a prostitute conducting her trade in the same hotel room at different times of the day.

The prospect of sixteen minutes of minimalist sludge metal in closing effort, ‘Scene 5: Breathing Fire’, mixed with another angry sermon externalised as hatred for the history of man and empire might fill you with dread – never mind tedium. Things come to life at 04:10 when the guitars, bass and drums get into gear and Moor Mother grits her teeth: “They won’t be naming no buildings after me to model and remodel / I pray the tides go the way of the wolves / Take warning/ Take caution.” You might experience a pang of guilt for praying that it’ll end after seven minutes.

We can ask – is this entertaining? Is this enjoyable? Perhaps these are the wrong questions. If the aim of art is to make you look at the world through a different lens, then, The Film achieves its objective. If only it had repeat listening value…


Verdict


Release Date: 25/04/2025

Record Label: Thrill Jockey Records

Standout tracks: Scene 3; Scene 4

Suggested Further Listening: Recoil – Liquid (2000), Emma Ruth Rundle & Thou – May Our Chambers Be Full (2020), Lotus Thrones – Lovers in Wartime (2021)