
Five years is a long time away from the music scene. Canada’s Protest The Hero suffered no writers’ block, but saw their career threatened by severe damage to frontman Rody Walker’s voice after their 2018 tour. Throw in a long period of vocal therapy and endless delays and it’s not without much blood and toil that we arrive at Palimpsest. But those who feared for the future of these prog-metal innovators have no reason to worry when they listen to this record, for this could be the finest concept album since Periphery’s Juggernaut Alpha/Omega.
For the uninitiated, Protest The Hero carved out a niche of their own in the late 2000s and early 2010s by occupying a unique spot in the middle of Sikth and Between The Buried And Me. Their influence is obvious on the likes of Periphery and Dance Gavin Dance, yet their ironic humour and likeability in college rock and hipster circles alienated some of the old guard.
Well, the good news is they’ve ditched the sound of art schoolers dabbling with prog-metal and gone full-on Queensrӱche Operation Mindcrime on this release. You want technical metal with fist-pumping lyrics and choruses to rival Iron Maiden at their imperious best – look no further. What about a narrative that follows generations of immigrants to America who slipped through the cracks and shared no glory in the manifest destiny of the nation? Yep, we have that too.
Opener, ‘The Migrant Mother’, is an instant classic with operatic rock vocals and a Grapes of Wrath perspective on going to California in search of a new life. The guitars cram in more scale runs than a Dillinger Escape Plan rehearsal and accentuate Rody Walker’s anthemic delivery without distracting from his voice. ‘The Canary’ and ‘From The Sky’ continue in this vain before we get to the frontier song, ‘All Hands’, which mixes At the Drive-In with a mathcore complexity behind the soaring melodic chorus. By this point it’s clear we’re listening to a great narrative through the eyes of individuals who sought America for a better life and ended up on the scrapheap with broken dreams. ‘The Fireside’ is Queensrӱche jamming with Botch while ‘Solioquy’ is worth a listen for the poignant lyrics alone. ‘In 1916, at 7 years old, I shot a kid in the mug with a found pistol/ First taste of the bracelets, first taste of the can/ Gave him a taste of the grave before his life began/ And all we know is all that we’ve been told,’ roars Walker. On ‘Little Snakes’ we can envisage the crunch of human skulls under foot as the band tackle America’s awkward history of ethnic cleansing of the native Indian population at Mount Rushmore.
This standard narrative of anti-American capitalism is not exactly original, but the band write with empathy and enough intelligence to avoid self-righteousness. They also throw a bone to the guitar nerds on ‘Gardenias’ with jazz fusion timings and some impressive bass runs. See if you can work out the time signatures in the prime verses of ‘All Hands’ and still breathe once it’s over.
The only criticism of this record is the band’s deriding of the American dream which comes close to aloof contempt. Many Americans will not take kindly to Canadians telling them their country is shit and built on bloodshed and lies. But would you prefer art that is apolitical, introverted and solipsistic? Of course not. Whether you agree with their interpretation of American history, there’s no denying this is a conceptual masterpiece that satisfies the technical metal crowd and the New York Times readership in one full sweep. Now that’s a first.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 19/06/2020
Record Label: Spinefarm Records
Standout tracks: Migrant Mother, The Canary, Little Snakes
Suggested Further Listening: Between The Buried And Me – Colors (2007), Queensrӱche – Operation Mindcrime (1989), At The Drive-In – Relationship of Command (2000)
