
Hummus Records gave us the monumental split release from Rorcal & Deadflesh last year (voted the SBR most extreme album of 2021), and now they present us with another piece of sophisticated extreme metal in the form of Neuchâtel quartet, Icare. A glance at the band’s promo shot shows four men in elegant but simple black clothing with folded arms. They might look like graduates of architecture school, but their music is far more savage than meets the eye.
Icare started as a studio project with no intention of playing live when they released 2020’s Khaos debut. But an abrupt change of heart prompted them to write Charogne, a 43-minute composition created with a live audience in mind. Like Celeste, the Swiss quartet are post-everything. Their moody guitars resonate with post-rock unease; their meaty metallic riffs offer a complete severance from the pentatonic foundations of the genre; and their black metal posturing uses abstract aggression for its might and menace. Indeed, the first two minutes subsist on an apprehensive angst of two guitars panned in each speaker – one feasting upon the ambient distortion of refined feedback, the other playing experimental jazz chords. Axel Vuille wastes no time in flying through the blast beats as soon as he hits his first drum note, yet the guitars only change to a higher frequency tremolo technique at 02:50 seconds. You might even hear shades of melody in the chord choices, but you know a nervous breakdown is imminent. It’s not clear which one of Cédric Prétat or Léopold Henchoz introduces the opening screams after five minutes of effervescent intensity, but Cult of Luna fans will appreciate the raw, single-tracked roars emanating from the microphone. Is this a kind of progressive grindcore we’ve not seen before? Mmm… Probably not. The music is too careful in its execution and too solemn in its emotional fervour.
Perhaps one of the biggest errors is to see Icare as a cinematic band. They take Charles Baudelaire’s poem, ‘Une Charogne’, as the inspiration for their vocal musings and aim to introduce changing dynamics in tandem with the structure and rhythm of the text. You can see what they’re trying to do, yet you can also imagine the guitarists clutching two impeccable white Gibson Les Paul instruments rather than the V-neck axes of their black metal forefathers. Aching arpeggio shapes and rapid drum fills dominate the sonic landscape here. There’s no doubt this is sophisticated art-school metal.
As a long-form composition, Charogne is impressive in its ability to change tempo and mood without you realising it. You’ll appreciate how the dissonant doom metal respite at the twelve-minute mark offers a welcome breather from the strong-arm blast beats and scraping guitar chords. Arnaud Maule’s bass scales bring new textures to the slower and more contemplative moments, yet the walls of guitar noise crush you like an endless horizon of Zulu warriors waiting to overrun your encampment. How do they stay in key using such obscure chords?
Charogne would merit the highest praise if slimmed down to twenty-three minutes. The musicianship and telepathy of the band members is of the highest calibre and never sounds like four artists pasting together eleven different songs with the help of interludes in between. Moments of climax arrive and dissipate again under the weight of their white-hot fervour. Indeed, the sludgy thrash riffs and gargling bass notes after twenty-five minutes pulsate like salted flesh wounds, but the last half of Charogne is more of a slog. Your eye wanders to your wristwatch. Your mind loses focus. Daydreams that were banal at the best of times become even more mundane among a cacophony of unmelodious chords and washing machine blast beats. Think Ulcerate but less dreamy and more lucid.
Icare warrant repeat listens with their second album, but each one diminishes your enjoyment for the next time. Charogne is too long and one dimensional in its contrasting use of dynamics. But there’s no doubt we’ll be hearing more from these Swiss experimentalists in the future.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 06/05/2022
Record Label: Hummus Records
Suggested Further Listening: Snøgg – Dan, Ko Je Vrag Vzel Šalo (2022), Rorcal & Earthflesh – Witch Coven (2021), Celeste – Assassine(s) (2022)
