Harvestman – Triptych: Part Two


Neurosis vocalist/guitarist, Steve von Till, is arguably the most famous person in experimental metal. As a member of the band that invented post-metal, his pedigree and influence is immense. As we said of Triptych: Part One, earlier this year: ‘It makes sense for a musician who pioneered the thunderous rage of post-metal to have an artistic outlet that allows for a different form of therapy. The mood here is calm but not blissful enough to be free from the harm of modern society.’ Now, he returns with part two of his ambient-folk solo project, and it’s a lot more underwhelming than its predecessor.

Forty-four minutes of drone music with no variation of dynamics is a struggle at the best of times, especially when you’ve already absorbed the first instalment and you know that a third part is to follow later this year. Opener, ‘The Hag of Beara vs. the Poet’, subsists on nine minutes of downbeat drums and dub bass merged with a droning synth loop. It’s a Sunday evening in a student bar, and you’re nursing a hangover, but you need to finish an essay by tomorrow. Moody industrial trip hop is exactly how you feel. It’s time to get serious and back on track rather than playing the hedonist. Here, the beats ease off at the five-minute mark as keyboard strings ghost in and out of the mix, but the hypnotic drums re-enter after a minute of contemplation. This is the audio expression of procrastination for a person with deadlines to meet.

Do you remember when you’d buy a CD maxi-single from your favourite band and devour every track on there, including three different remixes of the same song? It’s a similar experience listening to Triptych: Part Two. Minimalist drone music is often unlistenable, but ‘The Falconer’ is manageable if you can switch off your brain from the anxiety of overthinking. If not, then, you’ll soon become bored. Perhaps a better way to approach it would be to imagine that it’s sensory music for meditational purposes. ‘Damascus’ is the opposite in mood. Be warned of danger ahead with a brooding synth drone from A Clockwork Orange and a ritualistic drum rhythm infused with brass horns that sound more Latin than Arabic. You could use this as background music while tucking into a novel. It has a cinematic presence that’s neither too intrusive nor too innocuous.

Seldom does an album lose enjoyment when put under the microscope for a forensic analysis. Reviewing Triptych: Part Two is a wasted cerebral effort. Instead, you’d be better absorbing it as background music rather than analysing every minute detail in the mix. Let the music talk to you rather than teasing meanings from it through stubborn perseverance. ‘Vapour Phase’ is the traumatic flashback scene in the dark television drama about a detective who’s haunted by the death of his skipper. Musically, it sounds like a drone instrumental version of ‘Clean’ by Depeche Mode. ‘Galvanized and Torn Open’ might even remind you of specific sections of ‘Agent Orange’ from Music for the Masses. Unfortunately, playing the game of identifying other artists in the minimalist compositions of Harvestman is one of the few highlights of side B of this record. Including ‘The Hag of Beara vs. the Poet (Forest Dub)’ at track four is a pointless rehash of the opening song and just as long. Reading the small print of a home insurance policy is more interesting.

Even the best artists cannot avoid self-indulgence. On this occasion, Steve von Till needs to be shielded from sycophancy. Let’s be honest: this is inconsequential music.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 21/07/2024

Record Label: Neurot Recordings

Standout tracks: The Hag of Beara vs. the Poet; Damascus

Suggested Further Listening: A Clockwork Orange (Soundtrack) (1972), Sunn O))) – Black One (2005), Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross – The Social Network (2010)