
Why are all the good albums arriving late in the year as we approach November? Scream Blast Repeat prides itself on fair reviews, yet we keep dishing out the 8 out of 10 verdicts as if we’ve lost all perspective. There’s a reason for this: the quality of risk-taking in underground metal. Into this space steps Genital Shame, the project of transgender musician Erin Dawson. Critics of the hipster interlopers in black metal assume that people like her will grow bored of the genre and move on to something more befitting a subscriber to The New York Times. On the evidence here, that’ll not happen soon. Wellness Plan is as much about musical invention as it is the tormented introspection of its creator.
Is this an avant-garde record? The intro piece invites you into the effulgent melody of the alternative rock bands from the 1990s who never conquered the mainstream because they had no angst. By contrast, angst is ubiquitous in ‘Down Titration Strategies’. Here, low-volume screams echo in terror, not even daring to be double-tracked in the studio. The chord choices alternate between pseudo-jazz intervals and atonal finger shapes that no guitar teacher would ever consider as “music”. Yet melody is abundant here underneath the walls of noise. Root notes from the bass guitar hum beneath the busy drums and help to navigate the tempo modulations. The six-string phrasing has a cinematic quality to it, like something from a gritty cop drama of the 1970s but fed through a black metal grinder (see also ‘Górecki Peace’ later in the LP). Does it need to be seven minutes in length? A second listen confirms that it does. Look closer and you can see that Dawson wants to bring the traditions of classical music into this record. Those moments of near silence are as essential as the peak-velocity action.
Art is unique in that it can rely on passion as much as talent to communicate its message. Dawson has both. Every note from her Los Angeles studio has a purpose. You’d think she might leave some of the misplaced ones in the mix given the aesthetic, but she chooses not to. Listen to how the glowing melodies of ‘Spiced Loam’ go from the territory of ‘Pharaoh’s Dance’ by Miles Davis to Deafheaven. The weightless atmosphere of this song finds inspiration somewhere between Alice in Wonderland and the noise transgressions of Fleurety. One thing becomes clear: Dawson is far more than a bedroom artist with good intentions. She’s a serious composer. The pastel colours of ‘I Want to Die Before You’ present a paradox, yet the switch between a dream world of sugar bubbles and the realm of Transilvanian Hunger is seamless. Likewise, the spoken word sojourn of ‘Suicide Wellness Plan’ starts in a gentle stroll and ends in an apocalyptic storm.
This album’s strongest suit is its ability to stay within the confines of extreme metal while embracing an experimental streak. Of course, the obstacle to finding a wider audience is the vocal approach. Think Haela Ravenna Hunt-Hendrix with the tantrums of a 1990s screamo vocalist. Will you bare your teeth in empathy or cringe? This is a harsh sound with a perfumed elegance. Observe how the distorted bass of ‘Nucleus Accumbens Atrophy’ plays the sludge metal part as the guitar arpeggios sparkle in a glistening loop. The resolution comes when the instruments converge around the blast beats. A jazz-fusion solo appears without warning. How can so many ideas be harvested in one song in only five minutes? The gory death metal outro sounds like The Jesus Lizard riffing on the early Autopsy records.
Finding obvious flaws is difficult in this forty-six-minute drama. The riskiest composition on the record starts in a morbid mood with wispy tremolo changes and circular drum patterns. ‘Gratitude Meditation’ points towards a heroic path to the horizon where freedom awaits. Then it decides that it must get there using the dusty route under the moonlight. Riffs start and stop, shivering beneath palm-muted passages and grungy vibrato reminiscent of the Hellhammer demos. Forty seconds of gentle feedback swells at the five-minute mark suggest that Dawson has run out of ideas. It’s a forced intrusion rather than an organic transition, though the gratuitous screaming that follows is effective. Why does it feel like you’ll be under the spell of flutes even though they seldom cut through the density of noise? Only repeat listening will uncover its logic.
The musical risks on this LP matter far more than the surrounding discourse about safe spaces for trans and queer artists in metal and hardcore. And these risks work. Wellness Plan is an album for musicians as much as activists. How Genital Shame’s music develops from here should be of great interest to the underground metal community.
Kirk Houghton
Verdict


Release Date: 30/10/2026
Record Label: The Flenser
Standout tracks: Spiced Loam; Nucleus Accumbens Atrophy; Gratitude Meditation
Suggested Further Listening: Fleurety – Min Tid Skal Komme (1995), Cicada the Burrower – Corpseflower (2021), Liturgy – 93696 (2023)
