
We should be thankful to Sepultura for opening up thrash metal to the power and intensity of hardcore on their Chaos AD album in 1993. Some cite Slayer as the originators of this metallic embrace of punk, but they sailed the boat long after the event, re-writing their history to affirm a love of Minor Threat and Circle Jerks in the summer of 1982, when, in fact, they were imitating Venom and wearing make-up. Like Hatebreed, Sacramento quintet, Extinguish, are a band that take inspiration from the novel thrash metal discovery of hardcore in the early 90s and turn it 360 degrees on its head. Only this time they spice their tough guy crossover with the Floridian death metal sound of the late 1980s.
You might think you’ve selected Cause of Death by Obituary on your stereo when the first doom chords of ‘Final Sin’ ring out, but the rumbling bass notes put things right at 00:45 seconds and lead into the type of violent charge you demand from any hardcore band. Yes, they play d-beat drum patterns, but they also approach their street punk as if taking Machine Head’s Burn My Eyes as their sonic template. This is hardcore for metalheads. If you don’t believe it, listen to ‘Unconquered’, which uses Slayer’s mid-tempo crunch as a segue to a violent Cro-Mags stomp. Now you can understand why Sepultura considered the singer from Merauder as a potential replacement for Max Cavalera before settling on Derrick Green. The vocals are foaming at the mouth in their hyper aggressive roar and work wonders in conjunction with the onomatopoeia of the chugging guitar lines in ‘Illusion of Stone’.
Extinguish have a surprising amount of compositional parts for a band with no songs over four minutes in length. Rare do they deliver a simple verse-chorus structure, instead preferring to bait the listener with a series of stop-start rhythms and chugging grooves. The lyrics are not easy to decipher but vocalist Ian Bouchard delivers them with menace. “When I saw the truth you lost my respect,” he roars on ‘Illusion of Power’. His threat on the final track is just as violent: “Time to pay the fucking the price/ I’m the judge, here to take your life.” The breakdown that follows is the highlight of the EP and will send the pit into a frenzy of windmill kicking and punching when they unleash this on a live audience. Ouch!
Metallic hardcore might be the least indulgent sub-genre of extreme music, which makes it impossible to dislike and easy to engage with during the listening experience. It also places most artists in the ‘good but not spectacular’ category. The idea of dazzling with extravagant musicianship is anathema. Raw emotion and chunky guitar riffs are the order of the day. Extinguish offer their solitary surprise on ‘…Only Silence’, but that’s because the opening chords and vocal phrasing imitate ‘Pull the Plug’ by Death. Replicating the intro to one of the most famous death metal songs of all time is not something you’d expect to find on a hardcore record.
Though not intended as an easy listen, Extinguish’s eponymous EP is pleasing to the ear of the discerning extreme metal fan. They don’t mess around, nor do they hold back on the mosh-heavy parts. And they don’t sing about dungeons and dragons, either. The message is simple: ditch the bullet belts and get the knuckledusters ready.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 21/04/2021
Record Label: Creator Destructor Records
Standout tracks: Final Sin, Blood Runs Cold, …Only Silence
Suggested Further Listening: Violent Life Violent Death – The Color of Bone EP (2020), Obituary – Slowly We Rot (1989), Reserving Dirtnaps – Another Disaster (2020)
