
The most divisive band in metal are back with their fifth album, and the good news is they’re no longer a metal band. This reviewer always stayed clear of Deafheaven, despite the obvious charms and admirable bravery of 2013’s Sunbather opus. They must be doing something right if they aggravate the TRVE black metal underground, yet they must be doing something wrong if the likes of NME and The Guardian are praising them as masters of cinematic metal. Imagine if Scream Blast Repeat started reviewing punk music and declared Billie Eilish a saviour of the genre – we don’t need those on the outside making pronouncements about a genre they understand nothing about.
If you’re reading this, you either love Deafheaven or love seeing them dismissed as interlopers in the heavy music category. You can’t deny their influence – Deafheaven clones are out there and even mathcore bands like Pupil Slicer draw inspiration from their raw aggression. Which makes it all the more puzzling why the duo of George Clarke and Kerry McCoy decided now is the time to abandon the black metal component of their music in favour of a subdued saunter. Opener, ‘Shellstar’, starts with enough promise, but the vibrant major chords of Pavement and The Strokes remind you why the TRVE black metal crowd hate their music. Yet, if you can get past this and listen with an open mind, you’ll discover an emotive melancholy undercurrent to the song. George Clarke’s vocals have a dream-like quality to them and merge into the interplay of guitar pedals, bass, and drums with ease. ‘In Blur’ is almost as interesting. This one has a sorrowful shoegaze flavour and belongs on Alternative Nation rather than Headbangers’ Ball, like every other song on this LP.
Those of you who persisted with Deafheaven since 2013 and lamented their increasing tendency to abandon the heavier side of their music will be aghast at the indie-rock musings on offer here. ‘Great Mass of Color’ starts like cheery guitar pop weighed down with a shade of sombre introspection and delivers a pointless cameo of black metal aggression for the last of the six-minute running time. Closing track, ‘Mombasa’, does the same, only this time the explosion of lo-fi black metal makes the skin on your skull contract. Why can’t we have more moments like this?
Let’s be clear: this album should not be judged from a metal perspective but on the merits of its ethereal dream-rock, which sounds good on paper but never achieves anything like the promise shown in the opening two tracks. There’s nothing mystical or enigmatic about Infinite Granite. Once you’ve heard the first four songs, you’ve heard them all – clean guitars, reverb-drowned vocals, melodic distortions of noise, crystal-clear drum snares. ‘Lament for Wasps’ is what The Smiths would sound like if they got back together and tried to write progressive music. The lazy day vibe has its charms, but seven minutes of this fodder is excessive. Likewise, you can play ‘The Gnashing’ as many times as you like, but it doesn’t get any better. Embracing the most sterile and directionless indie rock is never a good decision.
Infinite Granite is a lethargic album for a band that once mixed Slowdive with Mayhem and championed Grave Miasma as much as their (inexplicable) love of Oasis. Miscegenating different music styles is seldom a bad thing, but Deafheaven show no signs of experimentation or innovation on this record. Perhaps the kindest thing we can say about their fourth outing is that it’s not as boring as Ghengis Tron’s comeback LP. Of course, NME, Rolling Stone, The Guardian and The New York Times will declare this a masterpiece of modern rock, but you should know not to be fooled by the hype machine.
Look on the bright side, at least we can stop caring about this band in the metal underground. The coffee-connoisseur vegan hipsters are welcome to them, but we’ll be happy to review the work of George Clarke and Kerry McCoy if they resurrect their old grindcore group, Rise of Caligula.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 20/08/2021
Record Label: Sargent House Records
Standout tracks: Shellstar, In Blur, Mombasa
Suggested Further Listening: Rolo Tomassi – Time Will Die and Love Will Bury It (2019), Slowdive – Slowdive (1990), Ghengis Tron – Dream Weapon (2021)
