Ice Nine Kills – Welcome to Horrorwood: The Silver Scream 2


It’s rare for an artist with pop punk and ska origins to evolve into a transgressive metal band with a macabre sense of humour and shock rock aesthetic. But that is how you’d describe Ice Nine Kills’ journey since their inception in 2000, which started with 2006’s Last Chance to Make Amends and took them to the brink of symphonic deathcore on 2018’s The Silver Scream. Now down to just one original member in vocalist and chief song writer, Spencer Charnas, the Boston heavy metal act are a regular feature on the American billboard charts, but can they convert the metal puritans with their latest effort to subvert the pop world?

There’s no doubt Ice Nine Kills can execute a mean streak of extreme metal when their mood takes them in this direction. They can also write a catchy chorus and are not afraid to shred their guitars. You might think you’re listening to the follow up to Pig Destroyer’s classic Prowler in the Yard when the first forty-seconds of ‘Opening Night’ announce that ‘The thirteen tracks that you are about to hear were long ago hidden away, deemed too grotesque by the American recording industry.’ It should be the cue for a blast of grindcore madness if you’re coming to this record with high expectations, but the band deliver a raucous waltz of gothic emo-punk with Slipknot dynamics and a bruising breakdown riff. One listen to the playful chorus is enough for it to lodge inside your brain regardless of your disposition and your opinion on melodic singing in metal. At times, you have to admit that the standard of songwriting is sensational. ‘The Shower Scene’ retells the story of Norman Bates from Psycho through the medium of an Avenged Sevenfold masquerade and a radio rock chorus that ought to annoy but somehow hits the sweet spot. Only a snob would dislike it, despite the strain of My Chemical Romance underpinning the adrenaline.

The choice of guest vocalists will make you scowl when you see the credits. Who on earth wants Papa Roach’s Jacoby Shaddix to appear on their record? Yet ‘Hip to be Scared’ might be the funniest metal song of the year in the way it takes American Psycho’s Patrick Bateman as its protagonist and lampoons his yuppy tastes with a parody of his deranged musical meditations. The seven-string breakdown riff here is pure fucking Armageddon. Likewise, the first thirty seconds of ‘Funeral Derangements’ is equal to Strapping Young Lad in its psychopathic intensity before they spoil it with an emo-pop chorus. In case you doubt their commitment to corrupting America’s youth, they bring in Corpsegrinder from Cannibal Corpse to liven up the metalcore aggression of ‘Take Your Pick’. It might be special pleading to burnish their credentials with the metal crowd, but it’s hard to dislike the fabulous Morbid Angel riffing and Lorna Shore breakdowns towards the end.

Of course, anyone approaching this album with antipathy towards emo will struggle to get through the thirteen tracks on offer. Is there a genre more irksome in rock music? ‘A Rash Decision’ will make you question whether anybody over the age of fifteen is the target audience for the music, just as the pop punk nonsense of ‘F.L.Y’ has you wondering how you ended up listening to this type of crap on a metal record. Take ‘Rainy day’ as an example of this confusion. It starts with a nu metal intro riff and demonstrates an impressive level of storytelling, but you feel like you’re listening to a heavier version of Fall Out Boy. ‘Wurst Vacation’ is another offender, interpreting Korn through the prism of metalcore and chunky death metal verses before the inevitable intrusion of the pop chorus undoes all the good work.

You’ll need a large amount of good will to get through this record, but the enjoyment levels are strong enough to keep you reaching for the popcorn. No one should have guilty pleasures when it comes to music, and Ice Nine Kills are worth more than that accolade. Welcome to Horrorwood is a thrilling piece of musical theatre with enough bludgeoning metal to keep the adults in the room scared as well as the kids. If only they could expunge those annoying emo pop elements from their songs…

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 15/10/2021

Record Label: Fearless Records

Standout tracks: Welcome to Horrorwood, The Shower Scene, Hip to be Scared

Suggested Further Listening: Bring me the Horizon – Suicide Season (2008), Slipknot – Vol 3: (The Subliminal Verses) (2004), Avenged Sevenfold – Nightmare (2010)