
Gatecreeper are a band the death metal gatekeepers and the hipsters both love, which normally produces a pang of scepticism. 2019’s Deserted was a decent offering but nothing new despite it’s hardcore punk-infused take on the malevolent Floridian sound. Their top spot in Kerrang! magazine’s Best Death Metal Bands in the World Right Now only added to this reviewer’s determination to stay away from the hype. On the evidence of this EP, he was foolish.
An Unexpected Reality is a beast of a record, and one that straps you in from the first note. Four of the eight tracks here are less than one minute in length, yet this is not a grindcore record, nor is it derivative. ‘Starved’ pulverises with a thick guitar tone as heavy as Machine Head and as violent as any New York hardcore band from the golden era of the 1990s. Yet the molten blast of death metal in Chase Mason’s voice is as strong as Obituary’s John Tardy (the master of the genre). ‘Sick of Being Sober’ and ‘Rusted Gold’ are just as furious in their miscegenation of hardcore and Floridian death metal. The latter has the spontaneous edge missing from the latest Frozen Soul record. Listen to those Benediction riffs and double kick grooves at the beginning. This is how you write a death metal song clocking in at less than one minute.
Start boiling an egg while listening to this record, and it’ll be ready to serve before you get to the closing track. ‘Amputation’ is thirty seconds of chunky metallic grinding; ‘Imposter’ is Obituary meets Bolt Thrower; ‘Superspreader’ is Gatecreeper flirting with the power violence genre. All will rabbit-punch you in the midriff before you can steady your body for the vicious assault. This could be the latest Scalp or Violent Life Violent Death record as much as a classic Malevolent Creation album.
But the band are not finished at track seven. No, they end the EP in style with a surprise doom metal epic of eleven minutes with the magnificent, ‘Emptiness’. You’ll find no punk in this one, just pure My Dying Bride death-doom. Indeed, the verses in the first half of the composition will remind you of ‘Your River’ from the Yorkshire legends. The ringing fifth chords are as heavy as Matt Arabello’s slow stick attack on the crash cymbals. Again, Chase Mason grunts into the mic with a mixture of high-pitched agony and guttural foreboding. Everything comes together in a dirge of monstrous Candlemass riffs with the occasional pluck of mournful clean guitar along the way. It’s enough to whet the appetite for the next album and a big enough departure to prompt the band into issuing a statement that ‘Emptiness’ in no way indicates a change of direction for the future. (That’s a damn shame!)
Sometimes we reviewers get it wrong. A listen to Gatecreeper’s 2019 album after this EP reveals all sorts of nuances that were not there on first listen. Now it all makes sense. An Unexpected Reality is the record that justifies the hype and adds new perspectives to the band’s previous output. This Arizona quintet are the Power Trip of death metal.
JVB
Verdict

Release Date: 13/01/2021
Record Label: Closed Casket Activities
Standout tracks: Starved, Depraved Not Deprived, Emptiness
Suggested Further Listening: Obituary – Slowly We Rot (1988), Violent Life Violent Death – The Color of Bone (2020), My Dying Bride – Turn Loose the Swans (1993)
