Mesh – The Truth Doesn’t Matter


Every review you read about synth duo, Mesh, in 2026 will mention two things. First point: they never receive their dues in their home country of England when northern Europe, especially Germany, learned to love them twenty years ago. Second point: The Truth Doesn’t Matter is their first LP in ten years, which means Donald Trump was leader of the free world on their last outing and is still the world’s most powerful man a decade later. But one thing is undisputed: Mesh are the finest electronic act to emerge from the United Kingdom since Depeche Mode. Indeed, 1999’s The Point at Which It Falls Apart and 2009’s A Perfect Solution can stand next to the best parts of the DM catalogue. All you metalheads that use the cliche, “I don’t just listen to metal; I have my Depeche Mode albums,” should pay attention.

You can always expect the opener to be a banger on a Mesh album. They start the title-track with the post-chorus vocals stripped of its beats and bass sequence and then land the groove with all instruments in convergence. It’s a clever songwriting technique. Mark Hockings makes great use of the spaces in this up-tempo number with his voice operating between a low baritone and a warmer head voice for the higher parts. The bass and drums feed off each other in that classic 1980s analogue setup where the former rumbles with a layer of fuzz as the kick-snare combination lands the money beat. You’ll only need to hear it once to sing the sceptical chorus designed for our “post-factual” age.

We move from the musical era of Thatcher to the era of Blair for ‘A Storm Is Coming’ as Richard Silverthorn’s arrangements takes us to the big beat thrust of the Chemical Brothers. Unlike the London duo, Mesh are songwriters and know how to lay a verse-bridge-chorus structure on the staccato techno furnishings. By contrast, ‘I Lost a Friend Today’ shows us that the Bristolians can compete with the Pet Shop Boys in the sorrowful stakes. Most electronic artists lack the ambition to introduce human emotion into their music. This challenge has never eluded Mesh. Ask the record-buying public of northern Europe. ‘Trying To Save You’ is The Human League beefed up with hard beats and a euphoric chorus to contrast the anxiety of the subject matter. The vocal lines are flawless here. You can envisage the lyrics appearing on a karaoke screen with the colours changing for each word. Speed it up or give it to a DJ, and they’d enjoy turning it into one of those awful Ibiza trance anthems that dominated UK pop culture at the turn of the century.

But Mesh don’t get everything right on this record. The second quarter settles into a maudlin torpor despite trying to keep things on course with the anthemic dance floor chorus of ‘I Bleed Through You’ and the forgettable languish of ‘Bury Me Again’. They’re in danger of fizzling out until they break the impasse with the hard-edge tempo of ‘Kill Us with Silence’ and then follow it with the majestic sweep of ‘This World’. Indeed, the latter is like a suave Tears for Fears with high reverb atmospherics and a blockbuster production. You’ll wonder if this group are capable of a mediocre chorus. ‘Everything As It Should Be’ is a stunning triumph of hard techno subordinated to a memorable bridge and key-change for the main singalong. The last Depeche Mode release was good, but it needed something like this effort to propel it into the top-half of their discography.

We live in uncertain times, and Mesh try to avoid closing their first LP in ten years on a fatalist note. It means the melodies are brighter and the tempo lighter for the final quarter. This ought to be the mature way to end things, but none of the final four cuts stand out. If anything, ‘Be Kind’ is the type of simplified “let’s all get along” cliché that Depeche Mode now regret when they look back on their famous single, ‘People Are People’. The stubborn refusal to move away from rhyming couplets is bad enough, but conjuring images of a wet Liberal Democrat telling us to be kind to each other is a spectacular misstep. Maybe the Germans will appreciate its candour.

Despite its flaws, The Truth Doesn’t Matter is still a strong record. Mesh are one of the few bands around that speak to the listener in a musical language they can appreciate and understand. It’s not quite Music for the Masses, Part II, but it would be a disservice to the Bristolians to make the comparison. Can you name one modern band that does the muscular synthpop melancholia better than these chaps?

Kirk Houghton


Verdict