
Architects are the textbook example of how modern metal struggles for appeal with the old school generation. It’s not through lack of trying. Nor is it because they dilute their heavy sound. But anything that takes the aggro of The Prodigy and layers it with electronic glitches will come up against some resistance. Maybe that’s unfair. After all, this is a band that stormed to number one in the UK album charts with their 2021 LP, For Those That Wish to Exist. They’ve had more of an influence on the last ten years of metalcore than Killswitch Engage and Parkway Drive combined. But will album number eleven see them achieve universal acceptance in the metal community?
A U2 guitar effect sets the scene for Sam Carter to lay down his vocal lines in memorable formation in opener ‘Elegy’. You can already hear how the chorus will sound when all instruments come in later on. Listen to the intensity of the hardcore screaming when the groove takes shape under the weight of monstrous down-tuned guitars. The only criticism is the chorus – it’s too long and drawn out even if the ambition is much higher than most metalcore artists. You might wonder if this is Korn’s Take a Look in the Mirror album revisited for the mosh riff at the climax.
Carter has a wonderful voice command in the melodic parts, but he also has a mean extreme metal roar, like Spencer Sotelo of Periphery. Architects are at their most exciting when they wade through the bodies with shoulder-bouncing riffs and apoplectic screaming. ‘Whiplash’ sees them gear everything towards the anthemic singalong chorus as a tension release. It’s nothing new, but they do it better than most of their contemporaries. Then comes the nu metal outburst at the two-minute mark. Are you ready for the Limp Bizkit standoff? If not, you will be for the hardcore breakdown at the end.
Unlike the last two records, you can find some real highlights here after two spins. ‘Blackhole’ is one such candidate. Carter stays in hyper aggression mode for most of the action until the change of key for the chorus. Dan Searle’s double-kick accents are sensational even if they received the digital perfection treatment in ProTools. Listen to the chugging riffs operate like a baseball pitching machine in angry mode. The guitar solo reminds you that this is not a nu metal record.
The main flaw of The Sky, The Earth & All Between is the template it might become for other metal artists considering a change in direction. Periphery would sound like this if they turned into a metalcore band and dropped the technical bedazzlement in favour of radio-friendly choruses. ‘Everything Ends’ is why Architects top the UK album charts. They can reach an audience beyond metalcore. It’s also why no old school metalhead will acknowledge their presence. The flagrant auto-tune in the melodic parts does them no favours, although the main vocal line is easy to remember after one listen. ‘Evil Eyes’ suffers a similar fate. This is exquisite groove metal until the event arrives for the singalong like a throwaway pop song. It’s a shame because the crunchy polyrhythms in the middle eight are superb.
Architects harvest some good ideas on this LP, not least their use of synths to fill the gaps. The production is clear and crisp, and the guitar tone is heavier than an asteroid. But this music is quite formulaic and enslaved to the idea of delivering an anthemic chorus in every song. “Some days I’m a tidal wave / Still lakes never leave a trace / I’m overcome but I don’t wanna run / Light fades but the shadows stay,” laments Carter in ‘Broken Mirror’. Imagine alternative rock through the prism of sorrowful boy band music. The skip button looms until they turn things around with an extreme metal outburst at the two-minute mark.
An album of high-tempo energy and melancholy anxiety makes for an easy listen. And that’s not a bad thing. But you can’t shake the feeling that the songwriting process is too easy for Architects. They could produce another LP like this in 2026 in between their world tour commitments. The chorus uplifts are tedious by time we reach ‘Curse’ (see track ten), yet there are some good ideas if you look hare enough. ‘Brain Dead’ makes good use of traditional hardcore tempos in the verse parts and takes great delight in rising through the octaves for the chorus. Adding electronic glitch effects and head-spinning single-note riffs leaves you panting in a plume of smoke at the end. Likewise, ‘Seeing Red’ is Architects primed for the boxing ring. Carter sees the mischief in introducing the riff with the “blegh” that turned him into a famous meme. You can’t complain about a lack of surprises here with the use of a child choir adding an extra dimension to the theatre of war.
Clearly, there’s some talent at play here, but it feels like Architects can bust out the anthems with too much ease. The mainstream metal press will love them for it, but will you?
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 28/02/2025
Record Label: Epitaph Records
Standout tracks: Blackhole; Elegy; Brain Dead
Suggested Further Listening: Erra – Erra (2021), Periphery – Periphery V: Djent is not a Genre (2023), Defocus – There is a Place for Me on Earth (2024)
