
Tayne is the vision of London-based Dubliner, Matthew Sutton. He calls his music industrial noise pop. A fan of extreme metal, he expanded Tayne into a live act with the addition of Tom Hancock (guitar) and Paul Traveller (drums). Gigs supporting Greg Puciato, Author & Punisher and HEALTH followed. This and collaborative work with Jesu and Mastiff helped to attract the attention of MNRK Heavy records. Now we have the debut album ready for dissection, and it’s bursting with ideas, many of them unrealised.
Tayne are not the first act to search for an equilibrium between dream pop and noisy metallic guitars, but they hope to be a pioneer in building it against an industrial setting. Exploring it as a musical idea beyond the work of Justin Broadrick’s Jesu project is fertile ground for those that want to try. The problem is finding the right balance between contrasting dynamics. Industrial music is repetitive and heavy on the crushing beats; shoegaze is solipsistic and formed from melodic distortions; pop music is often catchy and has a clear structure. Yet none of the songs on this record can claim to hold these together in harmony.
Stomping electronic crash beats perform the work of a conventional drum kit for the first forty-five seconds of ‘Erased’ before a tremendous roar brings in a head-banging fusion of electronics and noisy guitars. The vocals are ferocious and steeped in agony. But it’s over before you can adjust your posture. ‘Down’ is a bit easier to absorb. Ghost-like vocal melodies merge with zapping noise effects and a steady bass beat. The aim here is to pair minimalist electronica with abstract guitar textures. Listen to the hum of the machines powering it all together. It’s like Nine Inch Nails injected with the alternative rock of Swervedriver. There’s a strange serenity to it despite the staccato hammering that occurs at regular intervals. You can hear a post-metal fury waiting to break out, but it never arrives.
Tayne’s love of metal is evident in their choice of guests. Rachel Aspe of Cage Fight takes the mic for ‘Coherent’. James Spence of Rolo Tomassi provides a cameo of screaming on ‘Fear’. The former sees the drums and synth operate like a laser-fired weapon for most of the action. Aspe’s monstrous roar works well in contrast with the softer head voice technique of Matthew Sutton. In the latter, you wonder if this is what dream pop under the whip hand of HEALTH would sound like.
One cannot accuse Tayne of lacking imagination or new ideas. They show great wisdom in avoiding the simplified chug guitars and droning power chords that make industrial metal so boring. Instead, they let the beats and electronic manipulations carry the songs. That’s not to say guitars are underutilised here. ‘Wasted’ sees them unleash their inner Fear Factory and Ministry fantasies. The pop element comes from the melodious but unspectacular vocals. Unfortunately, Tayne persist with the limited-range vocal harmonies for many of these tracks. They’d be more suited to backing singer arrangements. Imagine somebody with their hands aloft and eyes closed, gyrating in front of you as if simulating a floating sensation. It’s enjoyable for the person enraptured in this mindset but less so for the spectator flashing glances at their wristwatch and wondering when the next train will arrive.
A lot of this LP sounds like those Nine Inch Nails remix albums that Interscope Records used to love releasing to hoover up as many dollars as possible. Is there a structure to any of these compositions? ‘Cause /// Worthless’ makes you realise that the lack of verses and choruses is deliberate. After all, shoegaze is electric guitar music for daydreamers. This’ll be thrilling in a live setting when you’ve no time to sit down and analyse the music in detail. But the listening experience is more sedate when you can scrutinise it with no distractions or prior adrenaline. ‘We’ is like Perturbator forced into a Slow Dive paradigm. Somehow, it doesn’t go anywhere.
It’s difficult to write memorable music when your tools are abrasive electronic beats, abstract synth clouds, and weak voice incantations. Add in glowing guitar shapes and aggressive dynamics, and it’s surprising how there’s still no tangible form to it all. Tayne deserve respect for restarting the conversation about a possible new musical frontier. Let’s hope they can bring it into being on their next record.
JVB
Verdict


Release Date: 31/01/2025
Record Label: Inside Job/MNRK
Standout tracks: Down, Coherent, Fear
Suggested Further Listening: Nine Inch Nails – Bad Witch (2018), Netherlands – Severance (2023), Jenna Leigh-Raine – Bloodsand (2024)
