Borer – Bag Seeker


New Zealand sludge metal quintet, Borer, are proud of the divisive effects of their art. They know that ninety-nine percent of the planet will dislike their music. Those of us in the one percent might not be as harsh, although you get the feeling that the band want their music to be disdained for being so ugly and will see it as a compliment if people detest it. So, we have the unusual task of making the case for something that most people will dismiss as low culture drivel. They don’t help their cause by posing for their promo shots in a waist-deep pond. What are we to make of the group’s debut album?

Opener, ‘Bag Seeker’, starts with an interview from Ozzy Osbourne talking about how he outgrew drugs but is no less stable in his life. Then, a fuzzy Black Sabbath riff kicks in with a slow groove and plenty of bass distortion. It’s regrettable that the vocals sound like a petulant child trying to make himself sick at the dinner table to prove a point that he hates vegetables. Electric Wizard meets Eyehategod is the formula here for nine-and-a-half minutes. As a southern geezer in England might say when confronted with something that vexes him: “Really?” The noisy high-register lead patterns are the most interesting aspect of this song, but you know what’s in store after just three minutes. Or do you? The reset to a fuzzy bass at 06:15 suggests they might have a surprise, but the vocalist uses it as an opportunity to rid his chest of catarrh.

Those fifty-five minutes in the top right of your screen will leave you dejected when you see the duration ahead of you. ‘Ket Witch’ is a song about the psychedelic effects of ketamine. To be fair, it lives up to its promise in the ambient guitar textures and subtle tom drum movements of the intro. This is what drone metal bands sound like when its practitioners start a longform composition. From an educational point-of-view, the person sampled in the speaking parts gives us a history of the drug and what differentiates it from other narcotics. A regular drumbeat enters just after the two-minute mark with slithery tremolo guitar techniques fed through a delay pedal with little in the way of velocity-picking. The bliss comes to an end at 04:20 with a painful vocal roar and sludgy guitars ramping up and into a generic riff after twenty seconds of deliberation.

Tom Brand’s vocals are too obnoxious on this LP to have an emotional impact. It gives the music a reprobate feel. Sludge metal communicates the anguish of depression and post-metal dwells in white collar rage, but this does neither. Likewise, the pointless instrumental, ‘06:32’, wastes two minutes and thirty seconds of your time on hostile wind noises fed through an emulator synth sampler with a recorded conversation of three New Zealand dudes having a laugh. You can feel your hand hovering over your mouth to catch a yawn.

The most disappointing aspect of this album is the unimaginative approach to the guitar riffs. These are as predictable as Manchester City winning the English Premier League for a fourth season in a row in 2024. This music would be more enlivening if Tom Brand shouted his way through ‘Wretch’ in the hardcore/post-metal manner of unleashing pain. He comes close here. A sudden cut to a clean guitar at 01:24 sketches out the chords for the next riff to follow. This is more like it – now Brand sounds like he has gallstones developing in his gallbladder due to high cholesterol. Borer threaten to end the affair at 06:30, but they choose to extend it with a busy drum interlude and return to the peat bog for an afternoon sleep.

Those that like swamp-infested doom metal that mirrors the slacker lifestyle of a stoner will find much to like here. The rest of us will be wondering how they can punish us with a closing track of twenty-one minutes (see ‘Lord of the Hanged’). Borer’s music is transgressive for the sake of being barbarous. We celebrate artists like Conan for their savagery, but we cannot fetishise everything that chooses to be anti-music.

At least the band achieved their aim of being divisive. But is that something to celebrate?

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 10/05/2024

Record Label: Landmine Records

Standout tracks: Ket Witch, Wretch

Suggested Further Listening: Conan – Evidence of Immortality (2022), Treedeon – New World Hoarder (2023), Iron Monkey – Spleen & Goad (2024)