The Answer Lies in the Black Void – Thou Shalt


The Answer Lies in the Black Void started in 2021 as a collaboration between Hungarian singer, Martina Horváth, and Dutch multi-instrumentalist, Jason Köhnen. SBR readers will know the former as a contributing vocalist on this year’s Thy Catafalque masterpiece; the latter is a big name in the European breakcore scene and a founding member of cult death-doom band, Celestial Season. They already play together in avant-garde electronica outfit, Mansur, but decided to form a side project for their shared love of doom metal. As musicians, they know each other’s instincts, but do they know how to stamp their authority on a genre that’s famous for its formulaic stubbornness?

On first listen, Thou Shalt ticks many of the boxes you’d expect from a generic soprano-led piece of European metal. The guitars often dither in the background like camouflaged animals too tired to pounce on you. Angelic voice harmonies echo into the wind as if hoping for the words to send out an SOS to a kindred spirit. And then there’s the lugubrious tempo of the music. You’ll find no reason to wake up tomorrow with a burning determination to cherish every minute of its existence. ‘Ataraxia’ is slow and sorrowful doom metal weighed down by the chains of a melancholy imprisonment. Horváth’s divine melodic vocals only add to the loneliness. Her voice is one that can sing to the trees and force a response from them in morse code. Köhnen’s guitar riffs in ‘To Kill the Father’ could be from any mediocre Lacuna Coil record from the last ten years. Droning fifth chords rumble like a libertine’s loins rather than the belly of a starving soldier.

The opening two songs rely too much on Horváth’s spell-binding voice, but a closer listen reveals many subtleties as the album progresses. Lingering doom chords in ‘Virgin Fire’ ache under melodious vocal harmonies that flutter like make-believe pixies. The thick guitar distortion wants to banish these fairy creatures, but a second channel of reverberating steel guitar effects leaves you with the courage to believe that daydreams are still possible. ‘Shadow Work’ follows in the same shade of pastel textures until the slow doom guitars force their way into the mix at 01:25. Listen how Köhnen derails the comfortable misery with an injection of double-kick patterns – this album is not just power chords and soprano phrasings. “I wish your pain to thrive! / To embrace your dark side,” roars Horváth in the one moment of malevolence on this record to emanate from her throat.

Seldom does a doom metal affair improve towards the end, but Thou Shalt is one of the exceptions. The riffs bare their teeth on ‘Jhieronymus’ as if revisiting My Dying Bride’s Like Gods of the Sun for inspiration. One assumes Horváth received a classical music education on the evidence of the title-track. Here she projects a lonely beauty in her voice as the piano lines dwell in the recesses of a heavy soul and search for a reprieve from life’s burdens. This song achieves a doom metal presence without the droning guitar chords. Instead, Köhnen lets the piano and drums provide the oxygen under a shroud of gothic keyboard swells. A surprising barrage of blast beats act as the catalyst for Horváth to push her voice through the octaves and into the heavens. This is how you work towards a climax and into a frenzy of emotions that can be untangled in the calm of a piano outro.

Closing track, ‘Vaporize’, helps you understand what you should already know. You can learn to co-exist with sadness and respect it as an entity that lives within you. It will never define you, but it will remind you of your humanity. Thou Shalt ought to be the last chapter in this saga before the duo search for new ways to indulge their love of doom metal on album number three. There’s enough here to warrant further listens, but The Answer Lies in the Black Void’s future lies in the daring self-discovery of striding further into the unknown. How they evolve from here will be the question both members should be pondering throughout 2024.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 13/10/2023

Record Label: Burning World Records

Standout tracks: Ataraxia, Virgin Fire, Shadow Work

Suggested Further Listening: Celestial Season – Mysterium II (2022), Theatre of Tragedy – Velvet Darkness They Fear (1996), Dismal – Via Entis (2023)