Signs of the Swarm – Amongst the Low & Empty


Pittsburgh deathcore crew, Signs of the Swarm, have endured a tumultuous nine years. Their original vocalist, CJ McCreery, departed for Lorna Shore in 2018 only to be released from his duties following damning allegations of coercive control (which appear to be fabricated). Likewise, Cory Smarsh (guitarist) and Jacob Toy (guitarist/bassist) left the band in 2021 after Facebook posts accused them of abusive behaviour. Founder member, Bobby Crow, started on the drum stool, switched to bass in 2016, and then returned to the sticks in 2020. Somehow, among this chaos, they managed to release four albums via Unique Leader Records and now find themselves on Century Media for album number five. This is a band that deserve a medal for perseverance and for their determination to continue writing music, but Amongst the Low & Empty will struggle to convert news fans to the cause.

The fact that they have a new album is a triumph for Signs of the Swarm. Maybe this is a stepping-stone to something greater in the future, but you’d expect a higher calibre of deathcore for a Century Media debut. It starts well enough. The opening title track will slam you to the ground like a professional wrestler. Have you heard anything as heavy as the drop-tuned Meshuggah riff that bursts out of the stereo from the first note? The way Carl Schulz alternates between the violent syncopation and the scale-shredding tech death rhythms speaks of a seasoned musician at the top of his game. Play this song on your headphones the next time you debate the merits of going for an early morning jog in December – you’ll be out of bed in no time.

Unfortunately, Shulz settles into the flat binary riffing beloved of those djent memes you see on the internet from track two until the end of this record. This poses a problem to those that like something other than low-end riffs that resemble the pop of a bicycle puncture fed through a sampling machine. ‘Tower of Torsos’ sails through a standard barrage of chunky palm-mutes and motors forward with the plastic drums that the members of Darkthrone execrate with all their venom. You’ll feel like you slipped into a river of deadly slime by the end of it. The kindest thing we can say about ‘Pray for Death’ is that it ends up as a self-fulfilling prophecy for the listener – will sleeping pills or a noose do the job? It’s an unpleasant daydream to have when listening to a tuneless version of Fear Factory.

You’ve done well if you reach track number five with buoyant energy levels. What happened to the Meshuggah influence? ‘Between Fire & Stone’ is yet another bludgeoning of flat guitar shapes and exaggerated vocal abrasions. To be fair, David Simonich maintains a high standard of grotesque mouth noises throughout this record. His brave decision to approach the clean parts of ‘Shackles Like Talons’ in the full deathcore mode works in his favour. The cameo appearance from Matt Heafy (Trivium) on ‘The Witch Beckons’ benefits from a more technical approach to the fretboard from Carl Schulz. It feels like a lifeline at track eight to experience something so invigorating.

But forty-two minutes of relentless deathcore built on boneheaded chug riffs and overproduced ProTools drums is too much to bear. The feeling that your neck muscles will stop working and will leave you in a permanent forward slump might prevent you from enjoying the strong ending to this record. ‘Faces without Names’ and ‘Malady’ are surprising highlights. The former includes a cascading high-register guitar pattern and reinvents itself as an aggro-synth affair for the last minute. On the latter, you can recognise the energy and intensity of the opening title track. It almost saves this LP from the fate of mediocrity.

Where do Signs of the Swarm go from here? The djent-core sound is a weary one that offers nothing but endless repetition and bleak musical tools for its creators to realise ever diminishing returns. Perhaps, their new deal with Century Media and settled line-up can produce something radical for their next album. Their current sound offers them limited hope for progression.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 28/07/2023

Record Label: Century Media

Standout tracks: Amongst the Low & Empty, Shackles Like Talons, The Witch Beckons

Suggested Further Listening: Aversions Crown – Hell Will Come for Us All (2020), Osiah – Loss (2021), Bodysnatcher – Bleed-Abide (2022)