
We know little about multi-instrumentalist, Josh Henderson, other than his love for the guitar. Born in the state of Washington (according to Encyclopaedia Metallum) and now a resident in Phoenix, Arizona (Bandcamp profile), he appears to have created The Final Witness in 2024. One wonders if he spent the last ten years studying prog metal but think again if you’ve written this off as a bedroom recording enhanced by Pro Tools software. Beneath the Altar is mind-bending, but it falls just short of greatness.
A fade-in of sliding power chords places opener, ‘Principalities’, into a Celtic Frost paradigm, yet Van Halen extravagance soon appears where you’d expect Satan. Clearly, Josh Henderson loves extreme metal and hard rock and sees no reason why they cannot serve each other outside the melodic death metal framework. His voice gushes with malice, but this axe works in an amalgam of styles. Can you imagine if Devin Townsend returned to playing music like this – harsh, inhumane, murderous, and yet celestial at the same time? Listen how Henderson pushes through the emotive blues soloing at 03:04 with the same panache as Dream Theater negotiating their way between transition points. A paean to Marty Friedman’s golden era in Megadeth follows. If anything, Henderson might overextend himself here by reaching for impossible standards.
‘Coronation’ is far easier to digest with its alternating staccato punch and thrash groove. Again, its creator sounds like a man with a liquid aphrodisiac running down his neck as the half-timing rhythms bury into your chest like circling vampire bats. The nearest reference is Edge of Sanity’s classic Crimson album from 1996, though Henderson shows more restraint in switching between the different styles of music. Most of the action takes place in the crucible of metal’s most technical genres. By contrast, the title track (song number three) is the closest he comes to a 1980s throwback, but he steers nearer to death metal than Judas Priest in the intro and grisly verse parts. He has five minutes to play around with, and he doesn’t want to squander them. But this attitude brings its risks as well. Why does this number turn into bubble-gum dance pop song with a bellowing guitar solo at the three-minute mark? You’ll wonder if you’ve walked into a Maroon Five gig for sixty seconds until the mood changes yet again to one based on solemn arpeggios vibrating like paper cuts to the fingers.
We already have proof of Henderson’s love for heavy metal and hard rock heroism, but ‘Sanctum of the Holy’ goes even further in its display of love for AC/DC’s finger-tapping flamboyance. Thirty seconds is enough before the muscular death metal smothers this in its cape. Perhaps the main flaw of this music is the way it struggles to bring you back into its orbit if you let your mind wander for twenty seconds. That leaves a sour taste in your mouth because you know the zealous enthusiasm of this album’s creator deserves you full attention. Beneath the Altar’s unwillingness to burn in the flame of mayhem or a more sedate pasture of introspection is what makes it a prog metal album. Which also means its ability to befuddle the listener increases tenfold. ‘Testimony’ can’t decide if it should be Steve Vai or Strapping Young Lad but the two meet on a common understanding that a guitar that weeps is a guitar that speaks to the listener. Ending it in the shadow of a church organ is ambitious but perplexing when you contrast it with the lick-your-lips rock of the sections leading up to it.
We mentioned Devin Townsend at the beginning, but Henderson has no desire to explore his voice outside the bloodthirsty voice technique. This might be a wise decision. Why attune your voice to a register for which it’s not capable if you can’t deliver? Focus on what you’re good at is an intelligent philosophy. Unfortunately, the quirky brutality that made the first half of this record so scintillating is what leaves you indifferent on closing track, ‘The Blood’. The musicianship and ambition are impressive, but you feel like a mouse trapped in a glass jaw, being rolled around by human hands. Even the passage to Ottoman Arabia in the middle section feels more like a chore than a descent into delirium.
There is no shortage of radical subtleties in this progressive metal framework, but a wider vocal range will be needed to keep up with them on the next LP.
Verdict


Release Date: 15/08/2025
Record Label: Rottweiler Records
Standout track: Coronation; Testimony
Suggested Further Listening: Strapping Young Lad – Strapping Young Lad (2003), The Final Sleep – Vessels of Grief (2023), Punks of the Empire – Gehenna (2024)
