
One of the hardest categories to curate is avant-garde metal. Identifying what’s progressive and what’s experimental and then separating the two with the latter in the avant-garde category is the main challenge.
For 2024, we chose albums that embrace experimentation and utilise non-traditional instruments and ideas. As the most fluid sub-genre, the artists warehoused in this category often join and leave the movement at the caprice of critics and fans. Few artists call their music avant-garde metal.
Perhaps the two most notable artists of the contemporary scene are Thy Catafalque and Zeal & Ardor. Both released albums in 2024, but where did they finish in our final list?
These are the SBR Top 7 Avant-Garde Metal albums of 2024…
7. Doedsmaghird – Omniverse Consciousness
What we said at the time: “If there is a formula to this album, it revolves around coupling and decoupling guitars and synths and using blast beats as the sticking glue when rhythmic derailment threatens to blow everything off course… Upending each song with daring new tangents at the most inopportune moment is harder to comprehend, although many of these experiments are successful in clearing the deck for new adventures.”
Country: Norway/France
Released: 11/10/2024
Label: Peaceville Records
Read the original SBR review here.


6. Sur Austru – Datura Strahiarelor
What we said at the time: “One moment, they strip everything back to bass and drums with mystical incantations. In the next instance, they strike the Tresillo rhythms and add gothic keyboard tones. The blackened death metal parts are sporadic but masterful, and so are the interludes of flute that act as a restraint on the stomach-cancer vocals… This is how you make black metal interesting again. The darkness at the heart of this music leaves you with a treacherous taste for homicide.”
Country: Romania
Released: 30/08/2024
Label: Avantgarde Music
Read the original SBR review here.


5. Suldusk – Antithesis
What we said at the time: “Music like this is so expressive and easy to conjure images of a fantasy world of your choosing. What can be better than something that enriches the imagination. You could even call it romantic in the way it creates a sense of wide-eyed wonderment for the natural beauty of the things that surround us… Antithesis is a mystical folk album with black metal elements rather than a blackened folk metal record. But the black metal aspects are impressive in their malevolence.”
Country: Australia
Released: 01/03/2024
Label: Napalm Records
Read the original SBR review here.


4. Zeal & Ardor – Greif
What we said at the time: “The project that started as a combination of Afro-American spiritual music and black metal arrives at album number four with its audience willing to join them for anything they please. In this case, they’ve ditched Mayhem in favour of Mike Patton and seem poised as the alternative for the metal crowd who cannot stomach Sleep Token… Though not as metal as the last album, Greif is no less stunning in its ambition and iconoclasm. Zeal & Ardor show that they are custodians of nobody’s legacy. They’re capable of creating their own.”
Country: Switzerland
Released: 23/08/2024
Label: Self-released
Read the original SBR review here.


3. Spineless – Dysphonia
What we said at the time: “Those expecting an exercise in virtuoso perfection will be surprised by the raw ferocity of Dysphonia… This is as intense as watching a woman being taken away by a lynch mob… Add in the distorted bass and grinding drum patterns and you have an album that can stand next to the latest effort from Julie Christmas.”
Country: Greece
Released: 01/11/2024
Label: Submersion Records
Read the original SBR review here.


2. Huntsmen – The Dry Land
What we said at the time: “Clearly, the prog rock greats of the 1970s are as influential on Huntsmen as Cult of Luna. The Dry Land deserves to take its place as the metal album equivalent of The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck… There are many novelty combinations in metal, some of them contrived and forced through with no coherence. Huntsmen have no such problem – Americana metal is real, and it’s as powerful as the vast desert in their hands. This is a calling of the wild.”
Country: USA
Released: 07/06/2024
Label: Prosthetic Records
Read the original SBR review here.


1. Thy Catafalque – XII: A gyönyörű álmok ezután jönnek
What we said at the time: “Like Alföld, this record goes hard on the metallic aggression in the first third… You can feel your spirit rising and possessing you to greater feats during the heavier moments… Track five is where the album departs from the metallic bludgeoning, but it offers no respite from the urgency of the previous songs… You wish Therion still played like this – ambitious, aggressive, powerful in tempo and texture.”
Country: Hungary
Released: 15/11/2024
Label: Season of Mist
Read the original SBR review here.


Honourable mentions

Killing Spree – Camouflage! (Klonosphere Records)
MOIII – MOIII (Someoddpilot Records)
Piah Mater – Under the Shadow of a Foreign Sun (Code666)
Ponte Del Diavolo – Fire Blades from the Tomb (Season of Mist)
Schammasch – The Maldoror Chants: Old Ocean (Prosthetic Records)
