In Defence Of… Paradise Lost – BELIEVE IN NOTHING


The staff at Scream Blast Repeat caused a stir when they published a discography review of the entire Paradise Lost back catalogue and awarded the band’s 2001 album a feeble 3 out of 10. (See the original feature article here.)

It caused a backlash and made us sit up and take notice of the strong feelings for this record. Admittedly, we looked at Believe in Nothing from the perspective of an extreme metal publication and did not see any merit in this album. Marc Dyos, drummer of Pythia and Phobetor, was so incensed by our scathing analysis, that he took us to task for our myopic stance.

Therefore, we invited Marc to make the case for this record in the first of our new feature series called ‘In Defence Of…’ where we’ll be asking our writers to defend controversial albums by great artists.

Marc rocking his Paradise Lost t-shirt in the recording studio.

“Leave the bullet-belt and spikey boots in the wardrobe for an hour or so and give this album a proper listen.”

I should probably start by saying that PL are my all-time favourite band, so it’s perhaps no surprise that I offered to jump to the defence of this much maligned album, although that doesn’t mean that I love absolutely everything the band have released. Medusa (2018) and Shades of God (1992) are good albums, but they don’t quite hit the spot for me because PL have always been at their best when writing ‘songs’. By this I mean verse-chorus-verse structures with strong memorable riffs and catchy melodies. ‘True Belief’, ‘One Second’, ‘Hallowed Land’, ‘Erased’ are some of the many examples of this.

Believe In Nothing is as verse-chorus-verse as you could probably get in the rock/metal world, and it is much more a rock album than metal in sound if not in spirit. It moves back away from the dark electronic ambience of Host (1999) whilst retaining a few samples and strings sections.

Greg Mackintosh (guitarist/songwriter) never speaks fondly of this album, but I can’t help but wonder if his views are influenced by his memory of the events and atmosphere within the band at that time. I have discussed this work with Lee Morris (drummer on this record), and the recording process also seems to dampen his view of the LP. He had to simplify his drum parts as the producer asked him to record drums and overheads separately, and the band all had to visit the studio at different times to record their parts instead of living together during the recording process, which they had done for previous releases. Therefore, it was a much more isolated and perhaps sterile recording environment than they were used to.

2001 was indeed a bad time for the band due to music industry problems, personal issues, intra-group clashes and musical differences following the controversial Host album. But PL music is about being miserable and melancholy, and what’s more miserable than an album made by five northerners who are going through a rough patch?

Don’t let the tempos or cleaner production fool you, this is a melancholy album through and through, and that juxtaposition makes for an interesting contrast. The album is also a snapshot of that point in time for the band (as any album is), which is why I wasn’t too impressed with the recent remix of this record. I don’t believe an artist such as PL should revisit albums based on where their heads are now as their music has changed so much over the years. That change of style and transcending of genres is what has made them who they are and is key to their longevity and consistent strong output of material. Yes, the guitar tone could be a bit heavier and the drum sounds a little weightier, but generally the mix is decent enough and is a part of what makes Believe in Nothing what it is, for better or worse.

The songs are packed full of catchy melodies and vocal lines and the classic jangly lead hooks, some of which wouldn’t sound too out of place on latest offering, Obsidian. Tracks such as ‘I Am Nothing’ and ‘Mouth’ have BIG memorable chorus melodies that stay with you, as well as one of my particular favourites, album closer ‘World Pretending’, which Aaron Aedy (guitarist) has said would fit well in their current live set. I wouldn’t disagree and certainly wouldn’t complain if it did. Unlikely, though, given the rest of the band’s views on the album. ‘Sell It To The World’ is a nod towards the darker, more pounding elements of previous PL efforts. One or two of these tracks may have even been considered PL classics if they’d featured on any other opus.

Great songs and songwriters can transcend genres, and PL have succeeded in doing that throughout their career. Yes, if you try to judge this album as a ‘metal’ album, it probably will fall short. But if you’re prepared to leave the bullet-belt and spikey boots in the wardrobe for an hour or so and give this album a proper listen and appreciate it for what it is, you’ll be singing along in no time at all.

P.S. I won’t attempt to defend the artwork…

Marc Dyos (drummer, Pythia and Phobetor) 


Verdict in Defence


Year of release: 2001

Standout tracks: I Am Nothing, World Pretending, Mouth

Suggested Further Listening: Difficult as Believe in Nothing is a pretty unique album and doesn’t even sound like any other Paradise Lost album. So, just pick any three PL albums. You can’t really go wrong.