
How do you create a shortlist for a genre that is hard to define and has no agreed boundaries? Does something qualify on the basis of being weird and abstract? To draw up our contenders for 2022, the artists had to meet the following criteria:
- The songs follow unorthodox structures
- They take inspiration from non-metal genres
- Non-traditional instruments are often an established part of the sound
- The music is aggressive and/or heavy
- Willingness to experiment with multiple sounds on one record
- Could fall into at least three sub-genres of the metal spectrum
Unlike last year, we include post-metal bands in the shortlist for 2022 as this genre is as close to avant-garde as it gets without earning the name. For the record, we did not review the new album from Ken Mode, but we acknowledge its originality. Likewise, Conjurer’s progressive sludge metal does not qualify for this list, although it meets a lot of the criteria.
Think of our current definition as a spectrum from left to right with the high-brow experimentation of Celtic Frost on one side and the bizarre genre-hopping madness of Mr Bungle on the other. Everything in between is what we looked for when deciding on the contenders and narrowing them down to a shortlist of forty-five records. These are the SBR Top 7 Avant-Garde Metal albums of 2022…
7. Ashenspire – Hostile Architecture
What we said at the time: “First thing we must do is dispel the notion that Ashenspire play black metal. Their music is far too sophisticated and much scarier than the infantile satanism that pervades through extreme metal’s most saturated genre. What could be more dangerous to society – harmless Lucifer worship or an earnest veneration of socialism in the perceived era of late-stage capitalism?… This is metal of the art school where Neurosis meet Thy Catafalque. You could even call it blackened post-hardcore, like a metallic interpretation of The Shape of Punk to Come by Refused.”
Country: Scotland
Released: 15/07/2022
Label: Aural Records
Read the original SBR review here.


6. Constellatia – Magisterial Romance
What we said at the time: “The unsatisfactory label of blackgaze does not apply to Constellatia. They draw from the same influences as Deaf Heaven and Alcest but inhabit a fluorescent post-metal paradox that never fails to move you with its awesome power and purpose. Like their debut, this album exists on the basis of four longform compositions spread over thirty-eight minutes, all of which flow like the stunning waterfalls of the Jonkershoek Nature Reserve in their native Cape Town.”
Country: South Africa
Released: 11/11/2022
Label: Season of Mist
Read the original SBR review here.


5. Messa – Close
What we said at the time: “Nothing in the doom metal scene sounds as unique as the bewildering invention on display here. This is a progressive metal record where Al-Andalus meets Byzantium and modern England… Close demands your attention and imagination. It allows you to daydream on its terms but never independent of them. This is sophisticated metal music that draws its power from the art gallery and biblioteca as much as the furnaces and factories of Western Europe.”
Country: Italy
Released: 11/03/2022
Label: Svart Records
Read the original SBR review here.


4. Knekelput – Teloorgang
What we said at the time: “What’s the definition of a cult album? Surely, one recorded fifteen years ago and left to gather dust under a cloud of self-doubt and mental struggles? We have no idea why the Dutch experimental duo of Knekelput decided to put their art in the public domain this year, but we’re all the richer for it. Whether released in 2007 or 2022, Teloorgang sounds like nothing on this planet… The metal world needs artists that have no regard for rules or conventions. Knekelput are the type of band that experimental jazz musicians can enjoy as much as the black metal crowd.”
Country: Netherlands
Released: 25/10/2022
Label: Self-released
Read the original SBR review here.


3. Psychonaut – Violate Consensus Reality
What we said at the time: “The Psychonaut sound finds purpose somewhere between post-metal and prog-metal. This is music for the overthinker – the person who is neither left nor right wing, who operates within the system but could tear down the edifice of everything he built in a moment of colossal self-destruction… A Psychonaut composition presents the conundrum of man climbing out of the quicksand rather than succumbing to its lethal abyss. Keep this image in mind as you experience closing track, ‘Towards the Edge’. It might be close to thirteen minutes in length, but it represents a triumph of the individual over the eco-system that threatens to overpower him.”
Country: Belgium
Released: 28/10/2022
Label: Pelagic Records
Read the original SBR review here.


2. Eight Bells – Legacy of Ruin
What we said at the time: “Defining the enigmatic sound of Eight Bells will tie you in knots throughout the forty-five minutes of Legacy of Ruin but think of it as an ethereal doom metal take on Swans with the unbridled aggression of Neurosis and the funereal sorrow of the early Cure albums… There’s always the danger of harm at the back of your mind from an unknown and unseen assailant. The band sense this in the unease of their musical dynamics… We shall all perish in the end, and this is the record that can prepare you for the afterlife.”
Country: USA
Released: 25/02/2022
Label: Prophecy Productions
Read the original SBR review here.


1. Tranzat – Ouh La La
What we said at the time: “They look like they’re warming up for a Weezer support slot, yet they sound more like a progressive version of Faith No More. Now on their third album since appearing on the scene in 2016, the Gallic quartet have the heavy metal rulebook in one hand and a map of the world in the other. Ouh La La is a prog metal opus that will catch you off guard like a prodigal member of the family you last remember as a quiet child. How did something so impressive appear from nowhere?”
Country: France
Released: 01/04/2022
Label: Klonosphere Records
Read the original SBR review here.


Honourable mentions

Box – Cherry Blossoms at Night (Label: Miserable Pyre of Secrets)
Cult of Luna – The Long Road North (Label: Red Creek)
Sigh – Shiki (Label: Peaceville Records)
The Chronicles of Manimal and Samara – Trust No Leaders (Label: Self-released)
Zeal & Ardor – Zeal & Ardor (Label: MKVA Records)
