
English hermit, James Fogarty, is the artist you might not know. Shame on you if that’s the case. It’s understandable that Steve Wilson (Porcupine Tree) gets the plaudits as the country’s most forward-thinking and original prog rock/metal artist, but Fogarty is England’s answer to Devin Townsend and Ihsahn.
In the mid-2000s, Fogarty’s Ewigkeit project looked destined to spearhead metal into the next decade. Like Aborym, the media frothed at the mouth and wondered if Mr Fog could be the saviour of a genre in flux. Earache Records thought so and handed Fogarty a contract in 2003, which saw him release the two acclaimed albums, Radio Ixtlan (2004) and Conspiritus (2005). Yet ten years of constant recording took its toll on the Brighton composer and saw him abandon the metal scene in 2006 when he ripped up his recording contracts and retired Ewigkeit.
Fogarty returned in 2012 and re-launched Ewigkeit as a black metal-inspired artform, going back to his roots as one of England’s few BM composers of the mid-90s. Three albums later, his current record is the second EP to emerge in the last five months, prompting Scream Blast Repeat to wonder if Mr Fog is going through an intense period of hypomania. Depopulate is an acerbic work, always asking those questions about the Covid-19 pandemic that don’t sit right in the enquiring mind. Could there be a sinister conspiracy behind this global crisis? The staff at Scream Blast Repeat are less sceptical but somebody as articulate and outspoken as James Fogarty will always have a platform here.
We tracked down the man behind Ewigkeit and asked him about his rediscovery of the guitar as a compositional instrument and his thoughts on the current zeitgeist. It seems he also harbours a grudge against his former colleagues at Earache Records…

Let’s dive right in. Depopulate is keen to tackle the current Covid-19 times we are living through. With song titles like ‘Plandemic?’ and ‘The Great Reset’, it’s clear you’re not shying away from this topic on your latest EP. What are some of your worst suspicions about the corona virus?
I find conspiracy theories about current events really interesting, and they always intrigue me. As a result, that part of my mind that is susceptible to flights of fancy revels in them, and it usually leads to some music (Conspiritus, Disclose, XXIII, Depopulate, etc…). I can’t say that I am whole-heartedly on-board with them, but they do provide a great source of inspiration. Does that come from being an outsider of society? Paranoia induced by smoking too much over the years? It’s a blurring of the lines between reality and creativity that has me hooked. As for Covid-19, I think it’s easier to say what conspiracy theories are clearly bullshit. a) it doesn’t exist; Are you fucking kidding? A friend of mine has died, and another was hospitalised. It’s not only real, it’s terrifying. b) 5G towers are causing Covid-19? Shut up! That’s like linking the death of Glen Miller to the atomic bomb because they happened around the same time. It’s up there with the Flat Earth = Stupid.
The song ‘Plandemic?’ contains a question mark on the song title. What are your thoughts on the theory that a group of nefarious individuals created the virus for their own ends?
I think something didn’t seem right from day one of the lockdown. It kind of took me by surprise as a distant virus in China has been something of a regular occurrence since SARS, and I pay attention to international news quite closely. Quite early on, it was established that a high-security bio-lab was not only located in Wuhan, but that it was a short walk from where there had been a large outbreak at the “wet market” (where the cover story was that the virus had jumped from horseshoe bats to pangolins. Please!). Some other disturbing factoids about it: The lab was set up partly with funding from the US because such work had been deemed too dangerous in the US. Also, that a group of six workers clearing out a disused mine in China in 2012 (?) had all been struck down with a mysterious pneumonia-type sickness, and three of them died. It turns out that horseshoe bats were one of many living in the mine. Anything like that is going to interest the health authorities. And the military. Covid-19 is unique in that its ability to adhere to human cells is terrifyingly similar to HIV – a development that is viewed as unlikely to have occurred naturally. The main question for my enquiring mind is then: “Was it on purpose or by accident?” This obviously is set against the background of the antagonism between China and the US and the associated proxies (Korea, Hong Kong, Japan, Taiwan, India, etc., etc…) If it was an accidental escape, then all of humanity is to blame for letting this shit go on. If it is deliberate, then, it’s the first assault in a new type of war…
It appears the title track of your EP is named after a conspiracy theory that a clandestine elite of billionaires have the pernicious aim of reducing the human population by forced vaccination. Where do you stand on this subject?
We’re increasingly being conditioned by the media in many ways. One of the over-arching themes is that “humans are bad” (whether that be in regards to the environment, anthropogenic global warming, over-population, mechanisation of labour, famine, etc.). I think that some of those arguments are legitimate and some are horseshit. Fact remains, if you are “anti-human”, then you are going further than any dictator from history and seriously have a screw loose; set us an example and go first… On the less extreme end of that argument, yes, there are probably too many people to sustain a good quality of life. How far are the 1% willing to take that, though? They have the infrastructure built up over hundreds of years and the benefit of technology that only comes from having a developed society – so they don’t need the “cattle” anymore. Would they go as far to deliberately cause mass death in order to secure their own future? It’s a fucking dark and bleak question! Sadly, I think a minority probably would. Is that what Covid19 is about? Only time will tell.
Let’s move on to the music. The metal riffs are colossal on this record. How long did you have them brewing before deciding to include them on Depopulate?
Hmm… I have been listening to extreme metal a long time! I largely write riffs from waking up with a hangover and picking up the guitar. I then record these on my phone (because I have a fucking terrible memory), and when I have four or five riffs that go together, I record them properly and arrange a song. After that, it’s a case of waiting until something comes up to use them for. As a rule, these days I record EVERYTHING because a) life is short and b) inspiration and enthusiasm are fickle and fleeting. I think the earliest track from Depopulate was from 2017, and the others were written in 2019/20.

Which artists and albums were you listening to when writing Depopulate?
Honestly, I don’t listen to much music – the riffs just happen without any influence. I’m not saying that there aren’t a shitload of really super-talented people doing great heavy music, but I’d rather spend time working on my own stuff. I do dip in and out of YouTube, and friends send me occasional stuff. I do hear a few new developments on death metal and black metal, but (and I don’t want to sound like an old fart) it really hasn’t changed since the early 90s. The production got better, but that’s about it. Plagiarism increased, and trends have come and gone, and there seem to be a multitude of micro genres, but I’m not personally getting knocked off my feet by anything. I really do want to hear something ground-breaking, exciting, socially conscious, genre-blurring, shocking, but perhaps I’m looking in the wrong places…
How much are you willing to say about the lyrical themes of opening track, ‘Patent of Death’? What is this song about?
It was a section of the banned documentary Plandemic, which was taken down off Netflix and banned by YouTube. I think banning stuff is always wrong as incorrect ideas should be argued, not policed by some tie-wearing fucktard towing the line of mega corporations. The same can be said for The Great Global Warming Swindle documentary from years back. Discrediting people through mainstream outlets without giving the opportunity for a retort and (even worse) ad hominem attacks are not the way to do things. It merely arouses suspicion.
You gave away your entire music collection to an Oxfam charity shop after releasing the Battle Furies album in 1997. We understand you did this because you did not want to be influenced by any artists. Yet many people who do something like this are in a dark place. What was your state of mind at the time?
Pretty bad to be honest. I was 17-18 years old, and it was probably the darkest period of my life, and one I don’t like to dwell on. Thank Christ I had parents and some friends who fully supported my will to be expressive and creative, and that is what got me through. Do what makes you happy, and you’ll get through it.
We are led to believe you grew disillusioned with music and metal in general after releasing the critically acclaimed Conspiritus on Earache Records in 2005. Your Wikipedia page says you burned all your record contracts in December 2006 with the aim of making all your music available for free online. What factors were responsible for this decision?
To be honest, I was apoplectic with Earache records. Whilst I think Digby [Pearson – founder of Earache Records] just did what he does (i.e. leave it to his staff to do their job), he had a right bunch of backward individuals on the payroll at the time. Anything that was a bit out of their comfort zone to listen to, they effectively black-listed in the office and didn’t actively promote. It’s even worse when you have people who are harbouring grudges on behalf of other, totally unrelated and jealous individuals. The release of Conspiritus was, in itself, worthy of a conspiracy theory… Anyway, fuck the lot of them. I politely approached Digby recently to offer to buy the two albums I did with Earache (2004’s Radio Ixtlan and 2005’s Conspiritus) as they were not “going concerns” of their catalogue. And the response was that he threw some hissy fit that would make Ru Paul proud; the response was to actually take down the releases from streaming services. Why? Maybe he was having a bad day. However, his unwillingness to be reasonable and give a direct sensible response, rather than through his mulleted and self-satisfied staff, means I will be dealing with him via the Musicians’ Union in the coming year or two. It’s not just utterly pathetic – it’s a breach of the agreement.

Why did you resurrect Ewigkeit in 2012 after bowing out with such distaste in 2007?
I needed time away from extreme metal. I had done a LOT of music in the twelve years leading up to 2007. Most of it was crap, but it was a personal journey and therefore is important to me. But it got to a point where it should have jumped up a level and, instead, I was working with idiots. Also, I think that it had left me in a situation where I needed to gather my thoughts, decide what I actually wanted to do and get “life” stuff sorted. Music went on the backburner for about five or six years.
We called you a born-again metalhead in our review of Depopulate. To what extent is this an exaggeration of how you came full circle in your musical evolution?
Hmm… I think you are right to certain degree. What needed to happen, and DID happen, was that I rediscovered my love for using the guitar as a compositional instrument, rather than using it as an afterthought (which was the case for a few releases for different projects leading up to 2007). I think I’m pretty much doing the best material I have ever done right now (whether for In The Woods, Old Forest or Ewigkeit).
The production on Depopulate is excellent. Tell us more about your recording and mixing process. Where do you record your music?
I write and record everything at home on pretty inexpensive but adequate equipment, other than the vocals (I use a local rehearsal studio). The reason I started Ewigkeit as a solo effort was because, in 1995/96 there were simply no black metal fans in Brighton who also played music (believe me, I looked and looked). That accounts for doing everything like artwork and production, which sort of became both a bane (not being able to play live, therefore extremely restricting your audience) and a boon (not having to rely on anyone and be totally self-sufficient). I basically get the mixes, so I am happy and then get someone else to master it for me (for ‘tis a dark art…) It’s good enough for me and keeps me constantly evolving.
What would your response be if one of the big metal labels offered you a deal for your next album?
Well, that will never happen. I’m pretty resigned to keeping on as I am. Ewigkeit is kind of my sketch-pad project where I learn, develop and experiment, but that also means I can do what the fuck I want! However, if Nuclear Blast or similar came knocking, I’d want to know I was working with fans of the music that would go the extra mile to do what they could to push it out there – not a bunch of blinkered knuckle-draggers.
Final question: What can we expect the next Ewigkeit album to sound like? When will it be released?
I’m into doing EPs for now instead of albums. Going forwards, the album is a dead format; the majority of music listeners are “swipers”. I heard a terrifying statistic that if you don’t get someone’s attention on Spotify within the first 5 SECONDS, then, they skip to the next song. How can an artist deal with that?! It’s funnelling everyone into doing jingles rather than compositions – really sad. Regarding the next Ewigkeit release, honestly, I have no idea how it will sound, but it will be during 2021.
*** Ewigkeit released Depopulate via Death to Music Productions on 23 January 2021. You can read the original SBR review here.
