

“It’s easy to write off Killing Joke’s last record for Virgin if you view it through the lens of a metal or punk perspective. This album… will baffle those who are new to the band and read of their influence on the Foo Fighters, Prong and Helmet.”
Metallica, Sepultura and Behemoth covered them. Napalm Death, Soundgarden, Faith No More, Ministry and Nitzer Ebb took inspiration from their early 80s albums. Voivod incorporated their distinctive guitar work into thrash metal. Dave Grohl played drums for their 2003 comeback album. We are, of course, talking about English post-punk legends, Killing Joke. But how many of you know that they transitioned into a goth band in the mid-80s and took it one step further with their 1988 album by embracing a keyboard-heavy Frankie Goes to Hollywood sound?
Most of America knows next to nothing about 1988’s Outside the Gate as it failed to see a release across the Atlantic and saw the band dropped by Virgin Records following it’s critical and commercial failure in the UK and Europe. The NME were vicious in their mocking review, calling it ‘a private breakfast of ideas, depicting poor old Jaz [Coleman] wading through quicksand with his jeans rolled down yet again.’ Bassist, Paul Raven (RIP), disliked the album so much, he asked to be removed from the credits. A retrospective embellishment of history suggests the record started as a solo project for frontman and vocalist, Jaz Coleman. Either way, it’s an album the band are keen to expunge from their discography.
It would be easy to ignore this record with the same delight Celtic Frost fans take in banishing Cold Lake from their memory. But our In Defence Of… series is a platform to do the exact opposite. We’re here to dissect the disastrous records of our favourite artists to see if the antipathy is justified. Thirty-two years after its release, we believe it’s possible to make a case for the rehabilitation of Outside the Gate.
The band don’t make things easy with the opening keyboard notes of ‘America’, a song that sounds more dated than Judas Priest’s guitar-synthesisers on Turbo. You’ll smirk when you hear the pompous concoction of Prince’s ‘1999’ with ‘The Final Countdown’ and might even switch off after thirty seconds, but that would be foolish. Once the laughter dies down, you should find a magnificent pre-chorus that could grace any classic 80s Hollywood sports film. Jaz’s vocals are unmistakable for their Oi! punk delivery and soothing southern English phonation, and what’s wrong with aiming a Freddie Mercury fist in the air every so often?
Killing Joke negotiated the early 80s with ease, switching from a dissonant punk band with proto-thrash leanings into a gothic rock act as early as 1984 when they saw what The Cure were doing and jumped on board by penning the classic ‘Love Like Blood’ from 1984’s excellent Night Time album. They continued to explore the majestic melancholy of Siouxsie and The Banshees on 1986’s Brighter Than a Thousand Suns, which saw them drop the heavier riffing in favour of a U2 approach. Track number two on Outside the Gate takes this to its logical conclusion with Jaz doing his best to grab some of Morrissey’s charismatic loneliness on ‘My Love of This Land’. It fails because it lacks the subtlety of The Smiths and tries too hard to capture the mood of post-imperial Britain. ‘Memories of gentlemen and cricket fade away in the hot summer/ But they still carry out traditions of the past without a meaning,’ laments Jaz. Decent lyrics but not the immortal lines the author envisaged in the studio.

‘Stay One Jump Ahead’ is a surprise departure from the mood of the opening two songs and showcases a funk sound with Oi! punk vocals and sampled horns that would not be out of place on a Michael Jackson record from this era. It’s not what you’d expect from a band that influenced grindcore and industrial metal, but fans should identify a sequel to ‘Victory’ from the predecessor record, with Geordie Walker contributing one of his best licks on the album. It’s true that the guitars are a sideshow on Outside the Gate, but Geordie lends his distinctive style to ‘The Calling’, which could easily make the cut for the band’s 1983 influential record, Fire Dances. An additional sprinkling of gothic horror keyboards will make you smile, but this song is a decent attempt to enhance the gothic sound they embraced on Night Time.
Perhaps the biggest criticism of this album is the determination to capture the zeitgeist of the Thatcher-Reagan era with biting satire and a helping of Morrisey’s vicious cynicism. At times, Jaz Coleman tries to emulate the miserable Mancunian with disastrous results. The goth fanbase they accrued between 1984 and 1987 are an afterthought when he snaps out of his Morrissey pastiche on a track like ‘Obsession’, which is nothing but a throwaway pop song taking geo-politics as its setting and a Sunday evening melancholy for its mood. Yet the band get it right on ‘Tiahuanaco’, this time sticking to reverb-drenched guitar arpeggios for Jaz to deliver his best vocal and lyrical performance of the album with an expert blend of keyboard melodies. His narrative feels sincere and his voice mixes his trademark snarl with the same soothing lamentations of ‘Love Like Blood’ in a glorious epiphany of sorrow at the way global capitalism destroys the beauty of pre-market societies. Only Neil Tenant of the Pet Shop Boys could capture the same moment in time with such poignancy.
A listen to the last song and title-track on their 1988 album reveals it to be a dated piece of bombastic keyboards and pitiful special effects, yet the guitar passages are quintessential Geordie Walker and Jaz’s vocal delivery is muscular and confident, perhaps because he imagined himself taking this music to the stadium arenas. This never happened and the band learned their lesson that trying to be like Simple Minds or The Cult would not cut it with their hardcore fanbase. Yet, unlike most bands at a crossroads in their career in 1992, grunge was kind to Killing Joke. People in the US knew little about Outside the Gate but remembered the proto-metal sound of their 1980 self-titled debut. Their famous lawsuit against Nirvana for ripping off their ‘Eighties’ single on ‘Come As You Are’ did them no harm, either.
It’s easy to write off Killing Joke’s last record for Virgin if you view it through the lens of a metal or punk perspective. This album contains neither of the two genres that define the Londoners and will baffle those who are new to the band and read of their influence on the Foo Fighters, Prong and Helmet. “How is that possible?” you’ll ask after listening to this slice of keyboard-heavy alternative pop.
Push aside your preferences for the heavier version of Killing Joke and imagine you’re listening to The Cure, and you should find something of value here. It’s not great, but it’s not the unmitigated disaster of rock folklore, either. And it’s only forgotten with such ease because the band returned to their guitar-heavy proto-Industrial roots on 1990’s Extremities, Dirt and Various Repressed Emotions. In our view, Outside the Gate deserves an upgrade from crap to semi-decent.
JVB
Verdict in Defence

Year of release: 1988
Standout tracks: America, The Calling, Tiahuanaco
Suggested Further Listening: Killing Joke – Night Time (1984), Ötzi – Storm (2020), Siouxsie and The Banshees – Hyena (1984)
