Pigpen – Agony and Irony


All artists like to think they put everything into their latest record. Sometimes, this is a lie, and not always for fraudulent reasons. Pressure to meet deadlines is one factor. Finding a comfort zone that satisfies the industry, the listeners and the creators is another. Some bands need to draw back on the current album for health reasons caused by the intensity of their last recording. Seattle trio, Pigpen, can hold their slumping heads high on their debut LP. It’s clear they unleashed every ounce of pain and anguish in the basement recording sessions for Agony and Irony.

You know this’ll be a turbulent listening experience from the intro track. A quiet rumble of thunder turns into an emerging tom drumbeat. This cuts in and out like a distant catastrophe that’ll be approaching soon. Noise effects caused by loose guitar leads add to the feeling of unease. Your ears are already flinching by the time the fuzzy bass riff opens the noise in ‘#Lie2Me’. Here, the despairing vocals and lo-fi beats are painful – deliberately so. You expect a doom guitar riff to add to the carnage, but this is a bass-led piece of angry sludge metal. Picture Cop Shoot Cop re-imagined through the eyes of Great Falls. The tempo-change at 01:29 is hardcore with no guitar. Drums pound away like an Agnostic Front number.

Pigpen’s music is as close to pain simulation as you can get, like the recent album from New York noise trio, Uniform. Imagine what self-harm might sound like if you put a philosophical junkie on a cold turkey programme without warning. Aaron Smith knows how to lay down a groove on his bass even if he plays it like an extra member of Helmet on the six-string axe. Press play on ‘Lineage’ for evidence of this. Here, vocalist, Rylee Baker, leaves his voice to crack and strain under the agony of screaming with no technique – it works. The pain is real and makes you wonder if you should be inside the head of somebody so damaged by competing anxieties. Perhaps there is guitar in this music – shrivelling clouds of feedback pierce through the low-end bass like a whistling kettle. Part two of this song begins with a new march of snares and a repeat scream of “We know what you are!” Your mind imagines Kurt Cobain doing an extended version of ‘Gallons of Rubbing Alcohol Flow Through the Strip’ with an uplift in suffering.

Everything used to record Agony and Irony sounds cheap, and that’s not a bad thing. The hollow kick drums, the single microphone captures for the instruments (excluding the drums), and even the strings on the bass feel like a studio engineer recorded them on the spot with no need to go beyond a ghost track. Smith’s approach is simple on ‘Straitjacket’ – play metal riffs on a distorted bass. The lyrics explore themes of stalking and extreme claustrophobia: “I’m going to the basement where no one can see me. I’m getting out. I’m never at peace. I’m going to the basement where no one can see me.” Much of this is like Helmet without guitars. You could put ‘The Perfect Joke’ on the same bill as a noise rock band or a hardcore act or even an avant-garde metal group. The lyrics read more like psychotic diary entries: “I will hold your head underwater like a baby and I’m not joking. Wish I could see the tired, wish I could see the shame. But now I’m never there. It’s like you never had me. I got a blacklist for shows this summer.” Perhaps it’s too close for comfort. Baker imitates the pain of a man removing an intestine through his gullet.

Add in a guitar and most of this would be orthodox sludge metal. Yet it has more appeal because of this sonic absence. There might even be a gallows humour in the lyrics to ‘So Obscured’: “It’s just one of those days / I don’t want to die / But when I cross / Those railroad tracks / I might slow downnnnn.” Baker imagines himself being held back by a group of responsible citizens who want to prevent him from murdering his mother’s killer. It’s lo-fi extreme metal with a mighty punch to the gut. Is he crying in ‘Two Pump Chump / Bullets Through Backs’ or exploring a high form of performance art? Every prolonged scream echoes like the last breath of a child dying from starvation.

You’ll need a strong stomach to get through this LP. Is this band aware of ProTools? Let’s hope they never discover the software. This is how you keep it real.


Verdict


Release Date: 09/02/2025

Record Label: Self-released

Standout tracks: #Lie2Me; Straitjacket; So Obscured

Suggested Further Listening: Helmet – Strap It On (1990), Kollapse – AR (2024), Nest – Endeavors (2024)