Skip to content
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • spotify
Scream Blast RepeatScream Blast Repeat
  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Features
14 February 2025 / Metal

Harakiri for the Sky – Scorched Earth


Austrian post-black metal duo, Harakiri for the Sky, inspire an astounding level of passion and recognition from their fanbase. The critics can be just fervent in their praise. Some believe their emotive music can push the metal genre to new heights. Scream Blast Repeat were more restrained in our approbation for their overly long 2021 album, Mære. ‘You’ll sigh when you see the length of each composition, and even the demarcation between disc one and disc two does not stop the experience turning into a labour of love rather than an intoxicating ride,’ is how we described it. Unfortunately, it’s the same problem with album number six.

Maudlin piano notes provide the landscape for a volume swell of guitars and slow drums to emerge in opener, ‘Heal Me’. J.J.’s vocals are impassioned but off key and lacking any form of tuneful enunciation. Of course, that’s the point – this is all about the here and now and the raw emotions. Musically, it’s like a post-metal band turning gothic. Harakiri for the Sky’s purpose is to keep the listener in a permanent state of burning agitation. The bass is loud in the mix, but the guitars are content to down-strum in distortion using little imagination. You think the climax cannot top the roar of blast beats at the six-minute mark, but they manage to sustain the tension for the rest of the song.

The piano motifs of this LP are easier to recall and hum along to after two listens. That’s a problem when you play metal. The guitars are uninspiring and of secondary importance for most of this record. Luscious piano movements sway like leaves in autumn in ‘Keep Me Longing’, yet you can already hear the tension before the drums enter. Shouting your way through this formation is an unusual way to release emotions. J.J.’s style is more in the mould of a hardcore vocalist than a shrieking black metal agony. It conjures images of a man left wounded in no man’s land with no hope of being recovered until his comrades can carry out a night raid. The effulgent pianos dominate and perform the role that melodic vocals would fill in a more orthodox rock song. There’s no doubt that Harakiri for the Sky present a paradox that’s now synonymous with them. Yet a romantic aching-heart is rare in this type of music: “Maybe someday we’ll be two people / Meeting again for the very first time / Time has taught us we’ve always been strangers / But in another life, I’m sure I’d make you stay.”

To be lovesick is an affliction that nobody would want to experience, yet it can also vitalise those that suffer from it. Melody is something this band have in abundance when you dig deeper into ‘Without You I’m Just a Sad Song’ and look past the shouting despair. They write high-tempo songs that would like to suspend time and place the listener in a slow-motion vacuum. But they place too much emphasis on the anguish of the vocals, when they’re nowhere near as poignant as their fans and critics would make you believe. A growled voice approach would be better than some of the single-tracked screams of pain on display here. And there’s not one guitar riff that’s memorable or does anything but provide a supporting function.

Is the aim to write a modern musical score for Goethe’s famous romantic novel, The Sorrows of Young Werther? The main surprise is the one-dimensional aspect of it all. Can you distinguish ‘No Graves but the Sea’ from any other song on the album? How many times have we heard the high-register guitar copy the piano or the words crack and pop under the strain of intense yelling? An hour of this raises the prospect of tedium. It’s a relief when we hear a looping synthesiser in the intro to ‘With Autumn I’ll Surrender’. The piano preset carves out its melody as easily (and just as predictable) as the Paradise Lost albums of the late 1990s.  Do you want to listen to an overdose of self-pity? “Like the last days of a suicide kid / Borrowing happiness from tomorrow / Still and always craving for summer / But for a summer so many years ago,” roars J.J.

This album could be so much better if the Austrians slimmed it down and stopped obsessing about their Sturm und Drang at the expense of everything else. A rare Placebo riff in ‘I Was Just Another Promise You Couldn’t Keep’ is intriguing enough to retain your interest near the end of the listening experience, but they envelop it with a shoegaze sadness and the grandiloquent roars that everybody seems to love about this band. J.J. sounds like a man descending on a bob sleigh with the gusto of a daredevil. You’re watching him accelerate downwards with a “bombs away” shout hanging in the air.

For a lovesick classic, look no further than Pretty Hate Machine by Nine Inch Nails. If Scorched Earth was twice the record it could be, it’d still be half of what you need.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 24/01/2025

Record Label: AOP Records

Standout tracks: Keep Me Longing; Without You I’m Just a Sad Song; I Was Just Another Promise You Couldn’t Keep

Suggested Further Listening: Svalbard – The Weight of the Mask (2023), Laang – Riluo (2023), Winterfylleth – The Imperious Horizon (2024)

SHARE

Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on WhatsApp Share on Reddit Share on Pinterest

Previous Post Confess – Destination Addiction

Next Post Neurostrike – Neon Uprising

CategoriesMetal Reviews

Tags6 aop records atmospheric black metal austria blackgaze harakiri for the sky post-black metal post-metal

Scream Blast Repeat

"Nowt but noise, lad!"

  • Home
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • spotify