Respire – Hiraeth


Toronto post-everything group, Respire, are the perfect band for Brooklyn Vegan – experimental, college-educated, concerned about the planet, and probably as passionate about fair-trade coffee as they are in their hatred for capitalism. “Why do they embrace black metal?” you might ask. But you could also be wrong in your lazy assumptions. Album number four has no axe to grind against a cast of villainous protagonists. We’re all responsible for the fate of the planet and need to take ownership of that fact. Musically, Hiraeth seeks to find beauty in chaos, but it goes about it in the wrong way.

Opener, ‘Keening’, offers a glimpse of a brooding riverside walk through marching drums and sorrowful violins. The low-volume screams rumble like the distant suffering of a person trapped in a mineshaft. Angling to put a beauty on this violent suffering is a challenge for any artist. The guitars are innocuous in the heavier parts, but more poignant when the drums drop out and their strings can resonate with more oxygen. Trumpets and violins take centre stage in the first reset of this song at 02:45. But is there a recognisable structure to this composition? Might we call this blackened post-rock? Five out of the six permanent members are vocalists – you never know which one of them has the microphone.

‘The Match, Consumed’ is more chaotic, like a fuzzy noise rock attempt at introducing black metal into the mix. Ben Oliver’s bass is louder than the guitars. The breezing violin motions are the easiest thread to follow. And you need something – anything – to follow in this music. Unfortunately, this song is a deliberate blur of materials and textures that deserve to be more perspicuous. ‘Distant Light of Belonging’ is just as incomprehensible. Think of it as trumpet-led post-black metal with no layers of interest. The scratchy guitar tone does not help. Is the idea to sabotage the golden silk of a choir arrangement and blemish it with tuneless noise?

There’s a lot of potential here when the rage takes over but no coordinated vision of what the music wants to be. Adding a college rock sentimentality to the canvass of ‘First Snow’ is a baffling decision, but it deserves a begrudging respect for trying to be different – even if it fails. Black metal screamo is as terrible as it sounds. Layering it with violins and trumpets ought to offer a reprieve, but it does it no favours in ‘Home of Ash’. Why this band need three guitarists is hard to explain. ‘We Grow Like Trees in Rooms of Borrowed Light’ is nothing more than Mogwai with trumpets before an abrupt switch to a messy blast of fuzzy metallic posturing at 01:24. It sounds like they used 15-Watt bedroom amps to record the guitars.

It’s odd (perhaps even tragic) that this band have the talent for cinematic music composition but have no idea how to write an experimental song that captivates the listener. Unless they want to create the illusion of improvisation on the likes of ‘The Sun Sets Without Us’ and ‘Voiceless; Nameless’? To be fair, the former explores an angular alternative rock with an interesting range of chord choices. The one-take scream vocals are more effective here as the brass arrangements pierce through the gaps in the amp distortion. The slower parts in the latter are like a half-hearted soundcheck.

An indie rock band playing post-metal has much to militate against it before you’ve even listened to one note. The trumpets are one of the most interesting features of this music, but this band must have the worst guitar tone in the world. It sounds as flat an old Walkman when the batteries start to die during side B of the cassette.

“Don’t cry if this is goodbye / If this voice is forgotten,” laments one of the five vocalists of the group in closing track, ‘Farewell (In Standard)’. It’s hard to think how this music could produce any tears of emotion when it’s so ill-executed and directionless.

JVB


Verdict


Release Date: 26/07/2024

Record Label: Dine Alone Records

Standout tracks: The Sun Sets Without Us; Do the Birds Still Sing?

Suggested Further Listening: An Autmn for Crippled Children – As the Morning Dawns We Close Our Eyes (2021), Sundrowned – Become Ethereal (2021), Demersal – Demersal (2024)