Six Feet Under – Killing for Revenge


Is there a more distressing sight than gleeful critics rubbing their hands together to denounce Six Feet Under as the most useless artist in death metal? Fronted by original Cannibal Corpse vocalist, Chris Barnes, and ready to release album number fourteen, it’s fair to say that this band are the punching bag for the genre. Their last three albums inspired universal hatred, which is unusual in any genre of music, but somebody must be at the bottom of the apex if we’re to appraise the situation as harshly as the critics. Are they really that bad? Now is a good time for this reviewer to weigh into the debate with no knowledge of their previous thirteen records or interest in their music.

With the expectations of others being so low, it’s almost impossible to dislike Killing for Revenge. Not because it feels noble to go against the prevailing consensus, but because this album is no worse than the last Cannibal Corpse record. Opener, ‘Know-Nothing Ingrate’, is vintage headbanging death-thrash with a pinch harmonic tag on the end. There’s nothing wrong with the guitar tone or clarity of the drums in the mix. Barnes is gruff and monosyllabic but not tiresome. The expressive guitar solo after the second chorus is like Andreas Kisser when he explores the fretboard with his thinking man’s hat on his head. ‘Accomplice to Evil Deeds’ is hardly a poor man’s effort. Listen to the awesome double-kick action with start-stop movements punctuated by drum fills. Why is there so much antipathy for this band? This is top-class death metal with tasteful lead guitar embroidery. Perhaps the Slayer influence is a bit too obvious, but it shines through on the latest Deicide record with just as much clarity.

Is the main criticism that this band know only one style? The death metal tremolo patterns are far better than the black metal equivalent on ‘Ascension’. Would you rather listen to ‘When the Moon Goes Down in Blood’ or forty-five minutes of dissonant death metal with no personality or aggression? The palm-muted arpeggio shapes are straight from the Death canon. Often, the biggest weakness of this genre is its tendency towards monotonous boredom – Six Feet Under stay clear of this pitfall after four songs. Their decision is a wise one at track five (see ‘Hostility Against Mankind’) to slow things down with a hanging groove of fifth chords played in the manner of Obituary. You can hear a clear Celtic Frost influence on the guitar riffing. Here, Chris Barnes goes into the vocal booth with dry pipes and does not double-track his vocals – does that deserve so much hatred on the internet? Listen how the bass introduces the new riff at the two-minute mark to accentuate the belch of the low guitar tunings.

Of course, the main problem of this record is its lack of originality. Though this music comes easy to Six Feet Under, they still need to clock in and perform at the highest level, like workers on a manufacturing production line. ‘Neanderthal’ works on an excellent call and response between guitar and bass in the opening death-doom riff even if repeating the song title as the chorus proves to be laborious. ‘Mass Casualty Murdercide’ is classic thrash metal with the self-conscious barbarism of old school death metal. You’d believe it if somebody said they’d invited Steve Di Giorgio to weave between the high-end bass scales in this song.

So, let’s address the vocals. Admittedly, Barnes sounds constipated on ‘Bestial Savagery’. But this genre gives no vocalist the room to be expressive. The process of adding voice arrangements to death metal music is like queuing up with your fellow junkies for a fix of methadone at the local clinic – you’re thankful that you can score, no matter the quality or the tragedy of your circumstances.

Side A of Killing for Revenge offers moments of genuine metallic quality. The second half is less interesting, but that’s a problem faced by ninety percent of artists in death metal. You’ll read many reviews denouncing this record as poor and unmotivated from those that love to hate Chris Barnes. Don’t be one of those people. Give it a listen and see if it’s as bad as the critics say. It’s not great, but it’s not as one dimensional as you expect.


Verdict


Release Date: 10/05/2024

Record Label: Metal Blade

Standout tracks: Know-Nothing Ingrate; When the Moon Goes Down in Blood; Hostility Against Mankind

Suggested Further Listening: Celtic Frost – Emperor’s Return EP (1985), Slayer – Divine Intervention (1994), Deicide – Banished by Sin (2024)