
Prog metal has many faces, from the progressive black metal style of Enslaved to the polyrhythmic leanings of modern bands influenced by Meshuggah. But is Tool prog metal? What about something as eclectic as Mr Bungle or Obsidian Kingdom?
We need to set a few ground rules to justify our inclusions in the best prog metal albums of 2020. It’s rare you’ll find two identical bands apart from in the djent/progressive metalcore sub-genre, where hundreds of bands ape the sound of Periphery and imitate the low-tuned guitars of Meshuggah. Experimentation with unorthodox time signatures is a hallmark of prog metal as is the restless urge to incorporate non-metal influences into the compositional approach. Yet it must have the aggression and guitar crunch of metal and shun the verse-chorus format in favour of more complex structures.
Eclecticism and genre-hopping have their place in prog metal along with virtuoso musicianship. But an eccentric fusion of incongruous musical styles belongs in the avant-garde/experimental category, a place where we would put the likes of Igorrr and Sigh.
With so many different interpretations of prog metal, it’s hard to define a specific scene. Perhaps the closest is the quadrumvirate of Caligula’s Horse, Leprous, Haken and Tesseract, all of whom draw on Meshuggah, Radiohead and Karnivool for inspiration. We see this approach in newer bands like Jinjer, Loathe and Toothgrinder. Then again the influence of Mastodon, Gojira and Opeth cannot be ignored, nor can the reach of Pain of Salvation, whose latest album is a masterpiece of innovative rock music rather than metal (and, alas, does not make our list for this reason).
No doubt you have your own definition of prog metal and may associate it with the earlier innovators of Queensryche, Dream Theater and Fates Warning (who also released a strong album this year). These forefathers have a place in the evolution of prog metal and their influence is evident in many contemporary artists.
So, with a minefield ahead, we give you the top seven prog metal albums of the year…
7. Neorhythm – Terrastory
What we said at the time: “Though rooted in the 90s groove metal era, Neorhythm are too forward-thinking to anchor their sound in the past. Their territory is the same as Jinjer’s modern take on progressive metal and has echoes of Born of Osiris. The novel polyrhythm between bass and guitar in ‘Empire Glory’ is worthy of Tool’s Fear Inoculum while ‘Information Age’ can rival anything off a Textures album for mosh-heavy offbeats.”
Country: Russia
Released: 20/03/2020
Label: Self-released
Read the original SBR review here.


6. Caligula’s Horse – Rise Radiant
What we said at the time: “The key to the Caligula’s Horse sound is twofold. Vocalist, Jim Grey, is on the register between Maynard James Keenan and Pain of Salvation’s Daniel Gildenlöw, yet he has the soul of Tracy Chapman. It’s a fine voice with a husky delivery at its most aggressive and an emotive falsetto for the sensitive parts. Backing him up is the virtuoso guitar duo of Sam Vallen and Adrian Goleby, who fret with the technical prowess of Periphery and shred like Dream Theater.”
Country: Australia
Released: 22/05/2020
Label: InsideOut Music
Read the original SBR review here.


5. Enslaved – Utgard
What we said at the time: “A key strength of Utgard is the consistent flow and effortless integration of different genres into a coherent framework. Progressive black metal is probably the most succinct description, but music like this is impossible to categorise. Another surprise is the duration. Compared with previous efforts, none of the songs here breach the eight-minute mark, and it’s a testament to Enslaved’s skill that they manage to showcase multiple ideas in only forty-five minutes.”
Country: Norway
Released: 02/10/2020
Label: Nuclear Blast
Read the original SBR review here.


4. The Ocean – Phanerozoic II: Mesozoic | Cenozoic
What we said at the time: “The greatest strength of Phanerozoic II: Mesozoic | Cenozoic is its rich variety of sounds. At no point does the listening experience diminish. This is because Robin Staps is aware that the best way to keep the listener engaged is to spoon-feed them illuminous melodies and hypnotic rhythms in between the distorted metal guitars and naked aggression. One moment we get violins, on another occasion it’s a synth bass or splash of minimalist electronica keeping the machine alive.”
Country: Germany
Released: 25/09/2020
Label: Metal Blade
Read the original SBR review here.


3. Protest the Hero – Palimpsest
What we said at the time: “The good news is they’ve ditched the sound of art schoolers dabbling with prog-metal and gone full-on Queensrӱche Operation Mindcrime on this release. You want technical metal with fist-pumping lyrics and choruses to rival Iron Maiden at their imperious best – look no further. What about a narrative that follows generations of immigrants to America who slipped through the cracks and shared no glory in the manifest destiny of the nation? Yep, we have that too.”
Country: Canada
Released: 19/06/2020
Label: Spinefarm
Read the original SBR review here.


2. Black Crown Initiate – Violent Portraits of Doomed Escape
What we said at the time: “If Black Crown Initiate did not exist, you would need to invent them. Imagine taking the rhythmic precision of Gojira, the low-tuned riffs of Meshuggah and the bewildering invention of Mastodon and combining these components in a science lab. This is what we get with Violent Portraits of Doomed Escape, an album that strides through the landscape of idols and admires them rather than smashing them up in a fit of monotheistic chauvinism.”
Country: USA
Released: 07/08/2020
Label: Century Media
Read the original SBR review here.


1. Haken – Virus
What we said at the time: “Looking ahead to the future is what prog-metal does best and Haken remind us that Tool’s pedestal is not insurmountable. You’ll listen to this record as if searching for the secret to the meaning of life and will memorise every note after three spins. There is no doubt Virus is an instant classic and sets a new benchmark in musicianship.”
Country: UK
Released: 24/07/2020
Label: InsideOut Records
Read the original SBR review here.


