
We reviewed 300 albums in 2024, and at least half of them were worth our time. The worlds of metal, prog and dark alternative produced some instant classics, but no overall trend dominated this year. It’s hard to think of a new artist that divided opinion or broke through into the higher commercial ranks. Maybe Knocked Loose filled this role thanks to an astounding rise to the top of the festival bills and a nomination for the Grammy awards. But they formed in 2013, and we cannot say they came from nowhere. So does the future belong to hardcore darlings such as Gel or Brat? We’re sceptical. It’s hard to see how these two artists can break the status quo despite the best efforts of the music press.
Some genres, like death and black metal, continue to churn out thousands of new records each year, while thrash and traditional heavy metal exist in a smaller universe. It seems that men in their mid-thirties prefer sludge and post-metal to cast off their shackles, while the youth of today are happy to resurrect nu metal rather than spearhead their own sound.
2024 had fewer big-name releases as new artists fought to be heard in a crowded eco-system. These are the SBR Top 50 albums of 2024…

50. Beaten to Death – Sunrise Over Rigor Mortis
49. Gost – Prophecy
48. Oceans of Slumber – Where Gods Fear to Speak
47. Pijn – From Low Beams of Hope
46. Melvins – Tarantula Heart
45. Zeal & Ardor – Greif
44. Ihsahn – Ihsahn
43. Urzah – The Scorching Gaze
42. Suldusk – Anthesis
41. Exist – Hijacking the Zeitgeist
40. The Jesus Lizard – Rack
39. Jerry Cantrell – I Want Blood
38. Grey Skies Fallen – Molded by Broken Hands
37. 200 Stab Wounds – Manual Manic Procedures
36. Nails – Every Bridge Burning
35. Verminthrone – The Cull
34. Huntsmen – The Dry Land
33. Candy – It’s Inside You
32. Mathilde – 32 Décembre
31. Hidden Mothers – Erosion / Avulsion
30. CNTS – Thoughts & Prayers
29. Vltimas – EPIC
28. Better Lovers – Highly Irresponsible
27. Spineless – Dysphonia
26. Totengott – Beyond the Veil
25. Giant Walker – Silhouettes
What we said at the time: “Giant Walker see no need to cram anything extravagant into their efforts, nor do they undervalue their ability to produce melody or see the need to focus on it at the expense of everything else. They can emphasise the power of the riff and the flow of the words like the introspective greats from Seattle.”
Genre: Progressive rock/metal
Country: England
Released: 20/09/2024
Label: Church Road Records
Read the original SBR review of Silhouettes here.

24. Immortal Bird – Sin Querencia
What we said at the time: “[Rae] Amitay’s voice roars with the freedom of somebody who learned to master their pain and turn it into an iron strength. Much of this LP will flash before your eyes like a close shave with death. Blast beats and furious guitars move like a typhoon through a village settlement.”
Genre: Extreme metal
Country: USA
Released: 18/10/2024
Label: 20 Buck Spin
Read the original SBR review of Sin Querencia here.

23. Thy Catafalque – XII: A gyönyörű álmok ezután jönnek
What we said at the time: “[XII] is just as unpredictable and imaginative as anything in the discography over the last ten years… This record goes hard on the metallic aggression in the first third. [Yet] the levels of excitement are palpable in every song.”
Genre: Avant-garde metal
Country: Hungary
Released: 15/11/2024
Label: Season of Mist
Read the original SBR review of XII: A gyönyörű álmok ezután jönnek here.

22. Kanonenfieber – Die Urkatastrophe
What we said at the time: “Horror film enthusiasts often react with disappointment when they buy a Cannibal Corpse album on the strength of its cover art. They expect the music to entertain them with the same alacrity as a Friday the 13th film. Seldom does this happen. But Kanonenfieber might be that rare marriage where imagery and music combine in harmony. You feel like you’re living through Ernst Jünger’s Storm of Steel memoirs..”
Genre: Blackened death metal
Country: Germany
Released: 20/09/2024
Label: Century Media / Noisebringer
Read the original SBR review of Die Urkatastrophe here.

21. Opeth – The Last Will and Testament
What we said at the time: “You need at least ten listens of this album to comprehend it. Parts of it are like the solo work from Ihsahn. An oversimplification would describe it as symphonic metal with guitar riffs of abnormal lengths and vocal melodies of unusual dimensions… But this music is easier to absorb if you treat it like an opera from one of the great classical composers.”
Genre: Progressive metal
Country: Sweden
Released: 22/11/2024
Label: Reigning Phoenix Music
Read the original SBR review of The Last Will and Testament here.

20. Wheel – Charismatic Leaders
What we said at the time: “The paradox of this music is its relaxing vibe despite the metallic guitar techniques. You can tap your foot and tense your chin muscles to the guitar riffs and lower your shoulders for the bass grooves. Good things come to those who are patient, but Wheel feed you with a constant stream of shape-shifting guitar patterns… Prog metal of this nature seldom becomes stale; few artists have the capability to write and play to this standard.”
Genre: Progressive metal
Country: England/Finland
Released: 03/05/2024
Label: Inside Out Music
Read the original SBR review of Charismatic Leaders here.

19. Knocked Loose – You Won’t Go Before You’re Supposed To
What we said at the time: “The secret to Knocked Loose is their knack for finding the groove in the most chaotic of movements. Isaac Hale loves to punctuate his riffs with death metal tremolo fills. Bryan Garris doesn’t bother to lower his voice to an unnatural pitch – that’s what gives it an air of anxious desperation. Those that think the debut Dillinger Escape Plan will take some beating as the most aggressive record of all time might think again after hearing ‘Piece by Piece’ and ‘Suffocate’.”
Genre: Hardcore
Country: USA
Released: 10/05/2024
Label: Pure Noise Records
Read the original SBR review of You Won’t Go Before You’re Supposed To here.

18. Kurokuma – Of Amber and Sand
What we said at the time: “You’ll need to play this album in running order to appreciate the interludes and ambient mood recordings that Kurokuma craft among the earth-shaking metal efforts. This gives the record a wonderful equilibrium and expands the emotions beyond bleak destruction and into a higher cerebral plain.”
Genre: Progressive doom metal
Country: England
Released: 09/08/2024
Label: Self-released
Read the original SBR review of Of Amber and Sand here.

17. MYNSKH – Chapter II – The Last Messiah
What we said at the time: “The tension in this music lies between its murderous rage and a strong will to throw off the chains of oppression. Guitars chug in each speaker as if determined to break through the popping barriers… Words bite at the microphone in the heavier moments with a permanent facial contortion. Many of the verses sound like execrations against the hubris of mankind.”
Genre: Blackened death metal
Country: Austria
Released: 13/09/2024
Label: Atmaah Records
Read the original SBR review of Chapter II – The Last Messiah here.

16. Unto Others – Never, Neverland
What we said at the time: “You’ll spend most of this record looking for a formula. That’s because the core elements that produce the Idle Hands/Unto Others sound are easy to identify. The question is how a gothic/post-punk band in 2024 can be so good when most of their contemporaries are often a mere pastiche… The guitar arpeggios guide the melodies of this album like glow worms in the midnight woodlands.”
Genre: Gothic rock
Country: USA
Released: 20/09/2024
Label: Century Media
Read the original SBR review of Never, Neverland here.

15. Hippotraktor – Stasis
What we said at the time: “Hippotraktor understand suspense. One moment the band roar like uncaged animals, but in another they seem happy to peer through the hole in the cabin door. Listen how clean post-rock guitar musings flip into violent metallic grooves that race into the smoke and flares like fearless protestors charging the riot police.”
Genre: Progressive post-metal
Country: Belgium
Released: 07/06/2024
Label: Pelagic Records
Read the original SBR review of Stasis here.

14. Heriot – Devoured by the Mouth of Hell
What we said at the time: “How hostile is this music? Each down-tuned crunch of the power chord feels like a blow to the head with exaggerated sound effects… Somehow, [Debbie] Gough succeeds in imposing her ethereal voice phrasings over the top of this windswept noise… There’s already talk of Heriot being a British export, and you can see why.”
Genre: Industrial noise metal
Country: England
Released: 20/09/2024
Label: Century Media
Read the original SBR review of Devoured by the Mouth of Hell here.

13. Inter Arma – New Heaven
What we said at the time: “You might think that more of the same will be on the agenda for album number five, but they return here with a shortened record of extreme dissonant metal unlike anything they’ve written in the past. What is going on?… Think of Voivod as an extreme metal entity if you want an interesting proposition. It has more changes than the heart of a diabolical liar. The guitars are as alarming as panic-inducing sirens.”
Genre: Extreme metal/Post-metal
Country: USA
Released: 26/04/2024
Label: Relapse Records
Read the original SBR review of New Heaven here.

12. GUHTS – Regeneration
What we said at the time: “The noisy guitars orbit the drumbeats like clouds waiting to unleash rain. Simple piano formations underneath the rubble hint at a Berlin vibe to match the New York noise approach. Perhaps Rolo Tomassi are a useful reference point for this music in the way GUHTS approach dream pop through the spectrum of post-metal.”
Genre: Ethereal doom metal
Country: USA
Released: 26/01/2024
Label: New Heavy Sounds
Read the original review of Regeneration here.

11. Utopia – Shame
What we said at the time: “Music as violent and as unpredictable as this is always in danger of alienating the listener. Not so with this LP. You won’t have time to switch off when you have a sergeant major barking in your face with a truncheon at the ready. It ought to demand many listens and many questions before you can understand it, but Shame leaves an impression from the first note.”
Genre: Extreme metal/Mathcore
Country: England
Released: 02/02/2024
Label: Self-released
Read the original review of Shame here.

10. Dawnwalker – The Unknowing
What we said at the time: “It’s true that there are few traces of the group’s post-metal aggression in this album, but it’s just as enthralling as their 2020 masterpiece. Mark Norgate prepared for this work like no other, immersing himself in meditational practises and esoteric spirituality. His goal: to better understand the vastness of the universe and the place of humanity in its infinite reach.”
Genre: Progressive rock
Country: England
Released: 18/10/2024
Label: Self-released
Read the original review of The Unknowing here.

9. Kollapse – AR
What we said at the time: “Some of the textures you can predict, but that’s only because Kollapse are masters at recreating the sound of a mental breakdown… Occasional melodies slip out of the neo-industrial entanglement of bass and drums, but these are abstract and unpretentious… The harrowing pleas of the scream vocals sound like a man fighting for his life in an abandoned mineshaft.”
Genre: Post-metal/Noise rock
Country: Denmark
Released: 08/03/2024
Label: Fysisk Format Records
Read the original review of AR here.

8. Iress – Sleep Now, In Reverse
What we said at the time: “The blurry textures are a permanent feature of this music and can become oppressive if you let them affect your listening experience. So, don’t. Instead, follow the emotions of the louder dynamics and let these be your passages underneath the waterfalls… This is just as much an album for guitarists who value the supremacy of textures over flamboyance and red emotions.”
Genre: Doomgaze
Country: USA
Released: 26/07/2024
Label: Church Road Records / Dune Altar Records
Read the original review of Sleep Now, In Reverse here.

7. Terminal Sun – All That Will Burn Is Already on Fire
What we said at the time: “From a mixing and mastering perspective this is close to Celtic Frost’s 2006 Monotheist album – you feel like your chest will rupture under the low-frequency weight of the amps. By contrast, the slower death-doom moments threaten to cut off your oxygen supply… Terminal Sun expect you to feel your way through the mist with open eyes and an unsteady balance. This band know how to write dark music that’s as lively as it is scary.”
Genre: Progressive death metal
Country: England
Released: 06/07/2024
Label: Self-released
Read the original review of All That Will Burn Is Already on Fire here.

6. Blood Incantation – Absolute Elsewhere
What we said at the time: “Cynic were the first to open this route to another dimension in death metal, and Voivod were the predecessors in thrash metal. Can the Denver quartet follow Gorguts in creating their own domain? Absolutely, yes. Their extreme metal credentials are not in doubt, nor do they use them as simple foundations to enjoy the more experimental aspects of their music. They embed them into their cosmos with ease.”
Genre: Progressive death metal
Country: USA
Released: 04/10/2024
Label: Century Media
Read the original review of Absolute Elsewhere here.

5. Julie Christmas – Ridiculous and Full of Blood
What we said at the time: “At her most unhinged, Jule Christmas sounds like Honey Bunny, the wife of Tim Roth’s character in Pulp Fiction, who attempts a disastrous armed robbery in a diner… She must be close to bursting an eye vessel when she switches from singing to screaming without warning… Much of this record is blood-boiling grunge with the aggression of post-metal and a hysterical performance at the microphone.”
Genre: Dark alternative/Post-metal
Country: USA
Released: 14/06/2024
Label: Red Creek
Read the original review of Ridiculous and Full of Blood here.

4. The Cure – Songs of a Lost World
What we said at the time: “Robert Smith is not in the mood to talk about lost love or celebrate sentimental memories in a three-minute pop format. Lyrics in Songs of a Lost World talk about “birds falling out of our skies” and “love falling out of our lives.” As the archetypal mope rock stereotype, you might expect The Cure to be prisoners of their glory years. They aren’t. This album is an exploration of growing old and dealing with the death of loved ones around you.”
Genre: Dark alternative
Country: England
Released: 01/11/2024
Label: Universal Music/Polydor
Read the original review of Songs of a Lost World here.

3. Chat Pile – Cool World
What we said at the time: “This record is darker than the reign of King Leopold II of Belgium over the Congo Free State from 1885 to 1909… Many artists long to create an existential nightmare in musical form, but Chat Pile bring their vision of alienation to life through blood and sweat… You can feel the righteous aggression of this music like an uncensored film reel broadcast to the public by mistake.”
Genre: Noise rock
Country: USA
Released: 11/10/2024
Label: The Flenser
Read the original review of Cool World here.

2. Mastiff – Deprecipice
What we said at the time: “Who knows what the members of Mastiff would be doing with their lives if they didn’t have an outlet in their mid-40s to unleash their frustrations onto the world? The groove in this music is the most astounding aspect when you consider the brutish nature of it… We already know Mastiff to be the heaviest band in England, and it will take a colossal effort to knock them off this perch.”
Genre: Hardcore/Sludge-grind
Country: England
Released: 22/03/2024
Label: MNRK Heavy
Read the original review of Deprecipice here.

1. Horndal – Head Hammer Man
What we said at the time: “Not since Black Crown Initiate’s 2020 swansong have we heard something so unsettling and yet so humane. What do you even call this music – sludge metal, prog metal, heavy metal? The showmanship is just as impressive as the storytelling. You can hear a psychedelic element trying to break through in the music. But, of course, this is a story of industrial strife, and there is no time to sit around and relax… It’s an angst-ridden assault with chest-rumbling guitars and clenched-fist vocals, and it has the riffs to match the words.”
Genre: Progressive sludge metal
Country: Sweden
Released: 05/04/2024
Label: Prosthetic Records
Read the original review of Head Hammer Man here.

